We often assume that our vehicles provide a protective shield, but the reality is far from that. Despite advances in automotive safety, accidents remain a significant threat. According to the National Safety Council, 46,027 fatalities resulted from motor vehicle crashes in 2022 alone.
While all vehicles carry some level of risk, certain models are more likely to be involved in fatal accidents than others. A recent analysis of data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) Fatality Analysis Reporting System examined vehicles from the 2018-2022 model years, identifying those with the highest fatality rates.
Karl Brauer, an automotive industry analyst, explained that these vehicles often earn top safety ratings in crash tests conducted by both the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and NHTSA. However, the high fatality rates may be influenced more by driver behavior and road conditions rather than flaws in vehicle design.
Below is the ranking of vehicles with the highest frequency of occupant fatalities.
1. Toyota Venza
Fatal Accident Rate: 5.6 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.0 times the average rate)
The 2022 Toyota Venza faced issues related to its Skid Control ECU software. This defect meant the vehicle did not comply with Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards, leading to software updates for affected owners. Although Toyota promptly addressed this issue, the high fatality rate suggests other factors, such as driver habits or road conditions, could be contributing to accidents.
2. Infiniti Q50 (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 5.8 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.0 times the average rate)
Drivers of the 2019 Infiniti Q50 have reported cruise control malfunctions and inaccuracies with the backup camera. Complaints have also arisen regarding steering issues that cause unintended drifting. This model has been a popular luxury sedan, but these technical difficulties, combined with driver error, may lead to dangerous situations on the road.
3. Tesla Model S (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 5.8 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.0 times the average rate)
Tesla vehicles have a history of recalls, and the Model S is no exception. Between 2017 and 2021, reports surfaced of phantom braking, where the vehicle would unexpectedly slam the brakes without an apparent reason, increasing the risk of rear-end collisions. Tesla’s advanced driver assistance features are designed to improve safety, but unintended consequences, such as sudden braking, may contribute to accidents.
4. Toyota Prius
Fatal Accident Rate: 5.9 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.1 times the average rate)
Despite the Prius’s reputation for reliability and fuel efficiency, it has been associated with a higher-than-average fatality rate. The compact size of the Prius may make it more vulnerable in collisions, particularly in accidents involving larger vehicles such as SUVs and trucks.
5. Dodge Charger
Fatal Accident Rate: 6.1 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.1 times the average rate)
Muscle cars like the Dodge Charger tend to have high crash rates due to their powerful engines and marketing geared toward high-performance driving. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) attributes some of these accidents to aggressive driving behaviors. The high horsepower of the Charger can encourage risky driving maneuvers, increasing the likelihood of severe crashes.
6. Ford Bronco Sport
Fatal Accident Rate: 6.2 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.2 times the average rate)
The 2022 Ford Bronco Sport has experienced recalls, including brake lining defects and powertrain issues that can cause the vehicle to stall, leading to increased crash risks. The compact size of the Bronco Sport, combined with its off-road capabilities, may also influence its accident rate, particularly when driven in hazardous conditions.
7. Ford Bronco
Fatal Accident Rate: 6.6 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.3 times the average rate)
The Ford Bronco has been subject to multiple recalls, including issues with rear door locks and improperly secured airbag sensors. The Bronco’s off-road appeal may also contribute to a higher accident rate, as drivers may take risks while navigating rough terrain.
8. Kia Seltos
Fatal Accident Rate: 6.8 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.4 times the average rate)
Some 2022 Kia Seltos models have reported stalling while accelerating or at a stop, increasing the risk of accidents. The 2021 model has also been associated with transmission failures. Despite its strong fuel economy and compact SUV appeal, these mechanical problems have raised safety concerns.
9. Kia K5
Fatal Accident Rate: 7.1 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.5 times the average rate)
The 2022 Kia K5 faced recalls due to improperly installed side curtain airbags, which could fail to deploy in an accident. Transmission issues have also been reported, causing a total loss of drive power. The combination of these factors may make the K5 more vulnerable to severe crashes.
10. Nissan Versa
Fatal Accident Rate: 7.2 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.5 times the average rate)
Despite earning accolades like the Consumers Digest “Best Buy Award,” the Nissan Versa has seen a high number of fatal crashes, raising concerns about its overall safety in real-world driving conditions. The Versa is a budget-friendly sedan, which may attract less-experienced drivers who are statistically more prone to accidents.
11. Chevrolet Camaro (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 7.3 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.6 times the average rate)
The 2022 Chevrolet Camaro received a strong reliability score from J.D. Power. However, despite having no major recalls, its fatal accident rate remains among the highest. Like the Dodge Charger, the Camaro’s performance-focused design may encourage aggressive driving.
12. Toyota Corolla Hybrid (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 7.3 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.6 times the average rate)
Although the Toyota Corolla Hybrid has no significant recalls and is an IIHS top safety pick, its seatbelt reminder system has been rated as “marginal,” which may contribute to higher fatality rates. As a hybrid model, the Corolla Hybrid is designed for efficiency, but its lightweight frame may make it more vulnerable to high-impact collisions.
13. Kia Soul (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 7.3 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.6 times the average rate)
While the 2022 Kia Soul has yet to see recalls, its 2020 and 2021 models have experienced piston oil ring issues, leading to engine damage and increased risks of crashes or fires. The compact size and affordability of the Soul may also contribute to its high accident rate.
14. Buick Envision
Fatal Accident Rate: 8 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.8 times the average rate)
The 2021 Buick Envision has had multiple safety concerns. A major recall was issued due to the failure of the airbag malfunction indicator, which means drivers were not properly alerted to airbag issues.
Additionally, certain models faced a recall related to exterior lighting issues, increasing the risk of nighttime crashes. While the Buick Envision is generally considered a luxury compact SUV, these recalls highlight the importance of vigilance when selecting a vehicle.
15. Kia Forte
Fatal Accident Rate: 8.1 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (2.9 times the average rate)
The Kia Forte, a popular compact sedan, has also faced safety concerns. In 2021 and 2022, a recall was issued due to improperly secured bolts in the steering column. If the bolt detaches, the driver could lose complete control of the vehicle. Given its affordability and high sales figures, these safety issues make the Kia Forte a concerning choice for many consumers.
16. Buick Encore GX
Fatal Accident Rate: 9.8 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (3.4 times the average rate)
The Buick Encore GX has received praise for its design and features, but safety remains an issue. Between 2020 and 2022, a recall was issued for its emergency jack, which could fracture if not positioned correctly.
This defect could cause the vehicle to collapse unexpectedly, posing a serious risk during roadside emergencies. Despite this, the 2022 Buick Encore GX was recognized as a Top Safety Pick by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
17. Mitsubishi Mirage G4
Fatal Accident Rate: 10.1 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (3.6 times the average rate)
The Mitsubishi Mirage G4, a subcompact sedan, has a relatively clean recall record, with no reported recalls for the 2022 model. However, it has notable weaknesses in crash safety tests. The IIHS found that its structure and safety cage did not provide adequate protection in crashes.
This deficiency dates back to a 2014 model test but remains applicable to 2017-2024 models. While the Mirage G4 is known for affordability and fuel efficiency, these safety concerns cannot be overlooked.
Also Read: 10 Best One-Off Cars That Pushed the Limits of Design, Engineering, and Automotive Innovation
18. Tesla Model Y
Fatal Accident Rate: 10.6 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (3.7 times the average rate)
Tesla’s Model Y, a highly advanced electric SUV, has encountered significant safety challenges. The 2022 model has been subject to 17 recalls, addressing serious defects such as a hood that could unlatch while driving and seatbelt alerts failing to activate.
Additionally, some recall targeted issues with Tesla’s self-driving system, which in some cases failed to stop at stop signs, did not properly follow speed limits, and even navigated vehicles into intersections improperly. Despite Tesla’s cutting-edge technology, these safety concerns are a major drawback.
19. Honda CR-V Hybrid (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 13.2 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (4.6 times the average rate)
While the 2022 Honda CR-V Hybrid has generally received positive safety ratings, it still has notable weaknesses. The IIHS gave it a poor rating for rear passenger chest injury prevention and a moderate rating for head and neck protection for rear passengers.
However, it performed well in driver injury prevention. As a hybrid SUV with strong fuel efficiency, the CR-V Hybrid remains popular, but rear-seat safety is an area in need of improvement.
20. Porsche 911 (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 13.2 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (4.6 times the average rate)
The Porsche 911, an iconic sports car, has faced several recalls. Some models had issues with seatbelts failing to secure properly, which could lead to detachment during crashes.
Additionally, certain 2020 and 2022 models were recalled due to improper welding of the vehicle body, reducing its ability to protect occupants in accidents. Despite its performance and luxury appeal, the Porsche 911 has shown concerning safety lapses.
21. Mitsubishi Mirage (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 13.6 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (4.8 times the average rate)
The Mitsubishi Mirage, the hatchback variant of the Mirage G4, has not faced any official recalls from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for its 2021 or 2022 models. However, its crash safety ratings are troubling.
The IIHS rated it poorly for driver lower leg and foot injury protection, and it received only a moderate rating for structural integrity. While it is an affordable and efficient city car, its high fatal accident rate indicates significant safety concerns.
22. Chevrolet Corvette (Tie)
Fatal Accident Rate: 13.6 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (4.8 times the average rate)
The Chevrolet Corvette, known for its speed and performance, has also encountered critical safety issues. A recall affecting 2021 and 2022 models was issued due to missing ball bearings that could lead to unexpected power loss.
Additionally, many 2021 models had faulty airbag malfunction indicators, which could fail to alert drivers to potential airbag deployment issues. While the Corvette is a dream car for many, its safety record leaves much to be desired.
23. Hyundai Venue
Fatal Accident Rate: 13.9 fatal accidents per billion vehicle miles (4.9 times the average rate)
The Hyundai Venue, a subcompact SUV, tops this list with the highest fatal accident rate. Between 2020 and 2022, it was recalled for seatbelt issues where the pretensioners (devices that tighten seatbelts in crashes) could explode and release metal fragments inside the vehicle.
This defect poses a serious risk to occupants in a collision. Despite being an affordable and practical choice for city driving, the Venue’s safety flaws make it a questionable option.
While all vehicles carry some level of risk, the models listed above have significantly higher fatal accident rates compared to the average car. Many of these vehicles have also been subject to safety recalls, highlighting the importance of researching a car’s safety record before making a purchase.
Whether due to structural weaknesses, faulty airbags, or dangerous driving features, these cars demonstrate that even popular models can have critical safety issues. Always consider crash test ratings, recall history, and safety features when choosing a vehicle to ensure maximum protection on the road.
Also Read: 10 Best Performance Hatchbacks You Can Buy in 2025 for Speed, Style, and Practicality
