In 2024, the Tesla Model S remains a benchmark in the electric vehicle market, but the landscape of luxury electric sedans has undergone significant changes.
Since its debut in 2012, the Model S has set the standard for long-range electric performance.
However, with the rise of competitors like Porsche, Mercedes-Benz, and Ford, Tesla’s dominance is being challenged by an array of compelling alternatives.
In 2023, Tesla discontinued the right-hand drive (RHD) version of the Model S in the UK due to “mechanical and logistical complexities” and to “ramp up production and improve quality more effectively.”
Customers affected by this decision were given three options: a £2,000 credit toward a Model Y or Model 3, the choice to purchase a left-hand drive version of the Model S, or the ability to cancel their order for a full refund.
This article will highlight the top alternatives to the Model S, evaluating crucial aspects such as range, performance, technology, and design.
While the Model S is not eligible for salary sacrifice through The Electric Car Scheme, every vehicle mentioned in this blog is so be sure to check out our quote tool for a personalized price based on your salary and lease terms.
Whether you’re interested in the iconic Mach-E or the sports car-inspired Porsche Taycan, this list offers a variety of right-hand drive options to match your driving needs.
Also Read: 10 Cars That Are Faster Than They Look and Pack Surprising Performance
1. BMW i5
The BMW i5 seamlessly combines electric luxury and performance, offering a sophisticated design, state-of-the-art technology, and an impressive range catering to both luxury enthusiasts and families.
As BMW’s fully electric midsize sedan, the i5 provides a smooth and refined driving experience, staying true to the brand’s reputation for high-quality craftsmanship.
Its sleek exterior blends aerodynamic efficiency with classic BMW styling, while the interior features premium materials, advanced digital displays, and a comfortable, technology-driven cabin.
The single-motor rear-wheel drive model delivers a range of 295 miles, while the dual-motor all-wheel drive version offers a range of 256 miles.
The electric powertrain ensures rapid acceleration, with the standard model reaching 0-60 mph in just 6 seconds.
For those craving even more power, the M60 model boasts an impressive 0-60 mph time of 3.7 seconds and generates 593 horsepower.
BMW has maintained its signature driving dynamics, making the i5 an appealing option for those looking for an elegant yet eco-conscious luxury electric vehicle.
It also offers a 490-litre boot 10 litres more than the BMW 3 Series making it a practical choice for any occasion.
While the Tesla Model S is widely praised for its performance, technology, and minimalist design, the BMW i5 is tailored for BMW enthusiasts looking to transition to an EV while maintaining the brand’s signature driving experience.
The Model S surpasses the i5 in terms of range and acceleration, but the i5 provides a more refined, everyday driving experience.
- Range: Up to 356 miles (depending on model)
- Charging: DC Fast Charging up to 205 kW, capable of adding around 100 miles in 10 minutes
- Technology: BMW iDrive 8, curved display, advanced driver assistance, AR navigation
- Design: Sleek, traditional BMW luxury styling, elegant interior
- Safety Features: Active driving assistant, adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, collision mitigation
2. Porsche Taycan
The Porsche Taycan is an exhilarating electric vehicle, representing the pinnacle of electric sports car engineering.
It merges Porsche’s legendary performance with cutting-edge EV technology, proving that electric vehicles can be both thrilling and sophisticated.
Designed for driving enthusiasts who crave speed and excitement, the Taycan delivers an unmatched experience.
Offering four power options, the lineup includes the base model ‘4’ with 476 horsepower, the 4S with 571 horsepower, the Turbo with 680 horsepower, and the high-performance Turbo S, which boasts an incredible 761 horsepower.
The Turbo S can achieve 0-60 mph in under 3 seconds. The Porsche Taycan 4 Cross Turismo is equipped with a battery that has a total capacity of 93.4 kWh, with 83.7 kWh of usable energy, providing an estimated range of around 220 miles on a full charge.
Charging options vary based on the setup. Using an 11kW home charger, a full charge from empty takes approximately 9 hours.
A 7.4kW charger at home extends this to 13 hours and 30 minutes. When using public fast charging, the Taycan can charge from 10% to 80% in around 20 minutes with a 216kW charger.
Inside, the Taycan’s cabin is designed for an immersive driving experience, featuring a curved 16.8-inch display behind the steering wheel that presents crucial information such as speed, power usage, efficiency, and navigation.
A dual-touchscreen setup enhances the infotainment system one main screen sits at the top, while a secondary lower display controls climate settings, boot and charge port functions, and infotainment shortcuts.
The Tesla Model S and Porsche Taycan take two different approaches to high-performance electric cars.
The Model S prioritizes efficiency, range, and autonomous driving capabilities, featuring a minimalist, futuristic interior.
The Taycan, on the other hand, is built for an engaging and dynamic driving experience, boasting precision handling, sports-car agility, and a driver-focused luxury cockpit.
- Range: Between 206-304 miles
- Charging: Up to 225kW at a DC fast charging station; can charge from 10-80% in 21 minutes at a DC fast charger
- Technology: Porsche Advanced Cockpit, dual touchscreens, performance-focused tech
- Design: Sports car-inspired styling, classic Porsche performance aesthetic
- Safety Features: Adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, 360-degree camera system, collision prevention
3. Audi E-Tron GT
The Audi E-Tron GT first made its way onto UK roads in March 2021 and received an update in the summer of 2024.
As a flagship model in Audi’s electric vehicle lineup, it shares its platform with the Porsche Taycan. Buyers can choose between two variants: the standard e-tron GT and the high-performance RS version.
The latest iteration of the e-tron GT comes with a starting price of £107,730. It offers a range between 364 and 374 miles on a single charge and boasts a top speed of 155 mph.
In terms of acceleration, the RS GT Performance is exceptionally quick, achieving 0-62 mph in just 2.5 seconds.
Inside, the cabin showcases premium craftsmanship, high-quality materials, and an advanced digital interface, creating a driver-focused cockpit that blends comfort with technological innovation.
The electric powertrain delivers outstanding performance, providing rapid acceleration and a smooth, refined driving experience demonstrating Audi’s ability to infuse its performance DNA into the electric age.
When comparing the Model S with the Audi e-Tron GT, the Model S is designed for those who seek an innovative yet practical vehicle, while the e-tron GT is tailored for drivers who prioritize style, craftsmanship, and a deep appreciation for the Audi brand.
- Range: 238-270 miles, depending on the model
- Charging: Up to 270kW DC fast charging, capable of charging from 5-80% in less than 23 minutes
- Technology: Virtual cockpit, MMI infotainment system, advanced driver assistance
- Design: Sleek, aggressive sports sedan styling, shared platform with Porsche Taycan
- Safety Features: Audi pre-sense safety system, adaptive cruise assist, active lane assist, emergency braking
4. Mercedes EQS
The Mercedes EQS stands out as a strong alternative to the Tesla Model S, offering the flexibility of choosing between a sedan and an SUV.
The EQS 450+ variant delivers an impressive range of up to 453 miles and accelerates from 0-62 mph in 6.2 seconds.
However, with a weight of 2,400 kg, it is notably heavy. With prices ranging from £105,610 to £119,610, the EQS represents Mercedes’ dedication to luxury and innovation, pushing the boundaries of what an electric vehicle can offer.
The EQS features a coupe-like silhouette, LED tail lights, and 5-twin-spoke light-alloy wheels.
Several advanced driving technologies enhance the experience, including adaptive air suspension, rear-axle steering, and an eco-assistant that analyzes traffic conditions and speed limitations.
Beyond its sleek design and cutting-edge technology, the EQS provides an exceptionally smooth and quiet driving experience, offering the kind of ride quality that has long been a hallmark of Mercedes-Benz flagship models.
When comparing the Tesla Model S to the Mercedes EQS, the Model S excels in range and acceleration, making it particularly appealing to drivers who prioritize speed and cutting-edge technology.
The EQS, on the other hand, emphasizes spaciousness and interior luxury, delivering a refined and comfortable ride. For those seeking superior comfort and a spacious interior, the EQS is an excellent choice.
- Range: Between 350 and 420 miles
- Charging: Up to 200kW DC fast charging, can charge from 10-80% in 31 minutes
- Technology: MBUX Hyperscreen with augmented reality navigation and an AI-powered assistant
- Design: Aerodynamic body, smooth lines, and a luxurious interior
- Safety Features: Active emergency stop assist, evasive steering assist, PRE-SAFE system
5. Ford Mach-E
The Ford Mach-E confidently redefines the electric crossover segment, blending Ford’s rich performance heritage with a practical and stylish design.
Positioned as a strong alternative to the Tesla Model S, the Mach-E offers an impressive range of up to 379 miles on a single charge.
For those seeking extra power, the GT Performance upgrade delivers an exhilarating 0-60 mph acceleration time of just 3.3 seconds.
Buyers can choose between a standard-range 70kWh battery or an extended-range 91kWh battery pack.
Inside, the Mach-E combines practicality with modern technology, featuring a large, vertically oriented touchscreen.
The cabin is designed for both functionality and comfort, offering ample storage space and seating for five passengers.
Buyers can personalize their driving experience with an array of standard and optional features, including customizable ambient lighting, heated front seats, a heated steering wheel, wireless charging, a panoramic roof, and even a front trunk lined with durable hard plastic.
If you’re considering an alternative to the Tesla Model S, the Ford Mach-E should be on your list.
- Range: 230-312 miles, depending on the model
- Charging: Up to 150 kW DC fast charging, reaching 10-80% in less than 45 minutes
- Technology: SYNC 4A infotainment, over-the-air updates, smartphone integration
- Design: Crossover SUV styling, muscular stance, modern electric aesthetics
- Safety Features: Ford Co-Pilot360, automatic emergency braking, adaptive cruise control
6. Hyundai Ioniq 5
The Hyundai Ioniq 5 stands out with its bold, futuristic design, characterized by sharp angles and geometric lines. It offers the spaciousness of a family SUV, ensuring plenty of room for passengers and their belongings.
Buyers can select from two battery capacities 63kWh or 84kWh along with different drivetrain options, including all-wheel and rear-wheel drive.
The Ioniq 5 comes standard with 800V charging technology, enabling ultra-fast charging at public stations. Performance-wise, the 84kWh battery version is impressively quick, accelerating from 0-62 mph in just 3.4 seconds.
Its distinctive, origami-inspired exterior pays tribute to Hyundai’s past while embracing an electric future, featuring elements such as parametric pixel lights and a cutting-edge modular interior.
The cabin is designed for comfort and versatility, incorporating a sliding central console and reclining rear seats ideal for longer journeys.
With a spacious, adaptable interior, a range of configurations, and competitive pricing, the Ioniq 5 is an excellent choice for those seeking a practical yet forward-thinking electric vehicle.
When comparing the Tesla Model S to the Hyundai Ioniq 5, the Model S offers superior acceleration and range, catering to performance enthusiasts.
In contrast, the Ioniq 5 prioritizes comfort, affordability, and practicality, making it a great option for families and everyday use.
While the Model S leads in innovation and speed, the Ioniq 5 stands out for its spacious interior, retro-modern appeal, and excellent value.
- Range: Between 220 and 303 miles
- Charging: Up to 350 kW fast charging, reaching 10-80% in under 18 minutes
- Technology: Large touchscreen, augmented reality head-up display, smart parking assist
- Design: Retro-futuristic aesthetic, unique angular styling, spacious interior
- Safety Features: Hyundai SmartSense, forward collision avoidance, blind-spot monitoring
7. Volkswagen ID.4
The Volkswagen ID.4 marks the brand’s well-thought-out entry into the electric crossover market, delivering a practical and accessible approach to EV ownership.
With an RRP ranging from £42,640 to £54,205, it stands as one of the more budget-friendly options on this list.
Buyers can choose between two battery sizes: the 52kWh battery in the Match model and the larger 77kWh battery in the Life Pro model.
The Match variant offers a range of 224 miles, while the Life Pro extends that to an impressive 337 miles. With a top speed of 99 mph, the ID.4 accelerates from 0-62 mph in 8.5 seconds.
Designed with mainstream consumers in mind, the ID.4 pairs clean, understated styling with practical functionality, creating an EV that feels both familiar and easy to live with.
Its interior prioritizes space and comfort, featuring a minimalist layout with user-friendly technology and excellent visibility.
Notable interior highlights include a leatherette-wrapped steering wheel, customizable ambient lighting, and an illuminated smartphone storage compartment.
The cabin is spacious, with a generous center console storage area and enough rear-seat room to comfortably fit three adults.
The ID.4 is positioned to bring electric driving to a wider audience by offering a well-balanced combination of comfort, range, and affordability, making the transition to an EV more accessible than ever.
- Range: 270-335 miles on a single charge, depending on configuration
- Charging: Up to 170kW DC fast charging, reaching 5-80% in 30 minutes at a fast-charging station
- Technology: Intuitive touchscreen, touch controls, connected services
- Design: Clean, modern crossover styling with practical family-friendly features
- Safety Features: IQ.DRIVE advanced driver assistance, emergency braking, lane-keeping
Also Read: 10 Cars with the Best Survival Rates in High-Speed Collisions
8. Used Tesla Model S
The pre-2021 Tesla Model S was one of the pioneering luxury electric sedans. In 2021, Tesla ceased production of right-hand-drive versions of the Model S in the UK, shifting its focus toward meeting the high demand for the more affordable Model 3 and Model Y.
Featuring a minimalist interior dominated by a large central touchscreen, the Model S set a new benchmark for in-car user interfaces.
Its powerful electric powertrain delivers acceleration that rivals high-performance sports cars, making it a standout choice even among newer EVs.
Despite being succeeded by more recent models, the used Tesla Model S remains a compelling option for buyers seeking a well-established, technologically advanced electric vehicle with a proven track record.
- Range: 270-335 miles
- Charging: Supercharger V2 up to 150 kW
- Technology: Large central touchscreen, over-the-air updates, basic Autopilot
- Design: Pioneering electric sedan with a sleek, minimalist interior
- Safety Features: Basic Autopilot, collision avoidance, automatic emergency braking