For decades, Consumer Reports has provided insights into the best new cars, focusing on road tests, safety, and reliability. Now, the same rigorous selection criteria apply to pre-owned models with the 10 Used Car Picks.
With rising new car prices, buying a used car is an attractive option, offering savings without sacrificing safety, reliability, or fuel efficiency.
This guide presents top picks across various price ranges, ensuring buyers find value-packed, dependable vehicles. Each model featured was assessed based on its reliability, performance, and safety features, making them excellent used car choices.
Consumer Reports selects used cars by evaluating how well they performed when new and analyzing long-term reliability data. Not all great new cars remain great used cars due to depreciation and reliability changes.
The chosen model years represent the latest qualifying versions within their price range, ensuring buyers get the most reliable and well-equipped vehicles. Automakers often refine their cars over time, meaning later years of a generation tend to be the best.
Standard features such as electronic stability control and advanced safety technologies further enhance the value of these used car selections.
1. 2016 Mazda6
The 2016 Mazda6 delivers a refined four-cylinder engine, sharp handling, and excellent fuel economy at 32 mpg overall. The stylish, well-crafted interior provides supportive front seats, though rear seat space is slightly tight.
The infotainment system, controlled by a console-mounted knob, may require some learning. Noise levels were reduced with the 2016 update, improving ride comfort. Safety features include forward collision warning, automatic emergency braking, blind-spot monitoring, and rear cross-traffic alert.
With a reputation for reliability and engaging driving dynamics, the Mazda6 is an appealing choice for those seeking a sporty yet practical midsized sedan.
2. 2018 Toyota Corolla
A compact car that offers midsize sedan practicality, the 2018 Toyota Corolla is known for its spacious back seat and smooth ride. Its 1.8-liter four-cylinder engine, paired with a continuously variable transmission, delivers 32 mpg overall.
While the highway performance is slightly noisy, city driving remains efficient and comfortable. Standard safety features include forward collision warning, automatic braking with pedestrian detection, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control.
Its strong reliability and simple controls make it a cost-effective, worry-free used car option. The Corolla’s reputation for longevity ensures it remains a smart choice for budget-conscious buyers.
3. 2016 Honda CR-V
The 2016 Honda CR-V blends space, efficiency, and reliability. The 185-hp, 2.4-liter engine paired with a continuously variable transmission provides a fuel economy of 24 mpg overall.
The spacious interior and standard backup camera add convenience. A 2015 update improved crash protection and safety technology, introducing forward collision warning, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control (on the Touring trim).
Ride comfort and cargo space are strengths, though handling could be sharper. Reliability is consistently high, making this CR-V a top pick for those needing a dependable and practical compact SUV with excellent resale value.
4. 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid
The 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid offers an outstanding 52 mpg overall, making it a fuel-efficient midsized sedan. Its 2.5-liter four-cylinder hybrid engine and continuously variable transmission deliver smooth power and impressive range.
A sleek design and spacious cabin enhance comfort. Standard safety features include forward collision warning, automatic braking with pedestrian detection, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control.
While its lower stance can make entry slightly challenging, the Camry’s reliability and efficiency make it a standout used car choice. Apple CarPlay was added in 2019, improving infotainment usability. Strong resale value and proven dependability make this a smart buy.
5. 2021 Kia Sportage
The 2021 Kia Sportage is a stylish and sporty small SUV with refined handling and a comfortable cabin. While visibility is somewhat limited due to design, the roomy interior offers supportive seats.
The base four-cylinder engine provides moderate fuel efficiency, but later models feature improved infotainment and additional safety features, including automatic emergency braking and lane-keeping assistance.
The 2020 update added a larger touchscreen and exterior refinements, making the final years of this generation the most desirable. With rising reliability and a competitive price, the Sportage presents excellent value in the used-car market.
Also Read: 10 Cars That Were Marketed as Reliable but Turned Out to Be Lemons
6. 2018 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid
The 2018 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid combines efficiency, reliability, and utility. The hybrid powertrain delivers 8 more mpg than the gas model while adding extra horsepower. The 2016 refresh improved styling, ride quality, and cabin quietness.
Standard safety features include forward collision warning, automatic emergency braking, lane departure warning, and adaptive cruise control. Reliability is well above average, making this an excellent used choice.
With a spacious interior and practical cargo space, the RAV4 Hybrid offers an appealing mix of fuel economy and versatility. Later model years within this generation provide the best blend of features and value.
7. 2020 Mazda CX-9
The 2020 Mazda CX-9 stands out with its sporty handling and precise steering, making it an engaging midsize SUV. While cabin space is slightly tighter than competitors, premium materials create a luxurious feel.
The turbocharged four-cylinder engine provides responsive power. A 2020 update introduced second-row captain’s chairs and pedestrian detection. The infotainment system was updated in 2021, but usability declined, making 2020 the optimal model year.
Apple CarPlay can be retrofitted by a dealer. Reliability remains strong, and its depreciation makes it a more affordable option compared to rivals. The CX-9 is ideal for buyers who prioritize driving dynamics.
8. 2017 Lexus NX
The 2017 Lexus NX offers luxury SUV practicality with a sporty edge. Based on the Toyota RAV4, the NX features a turbocharged 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine delivering 24 mpg overall.
The compact design results in a snug interior, amplified by small windows, so blind-spot detection is highly recommended. The cabin is well-appointed with premium materials. ]
For 2018, forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking became standard, making it a better value. Android Auto became standard in 2020. With a strong reliability track record and luxury features, the NX is a compelling alternative to mainstream compact SUVs.
9. 2015 Toyota Tacoma
The 2015 Toyota Tacoma excels in dependability and off-road capability. Its rugged design makes it a favorite among truck enthusiasts. The V6 engine and four-wheel-drive system provide excellent towing and off-road performance.
A 2012 refresh added improvements, offering buyers multiple model years of similar quality. Handling is somewhat clumsy, and seating positions favor shorter drivers, but reliability and resale value remain exceptional.
The rustproof composite bed adds durability. This Tacoma generation delivers proven toughness, making it a great used-truck investment.
10. 2019 Mazda MX-5 Miata
The 2019 Mazda MX-5 Miata is a thrilling sports car with nimble handling and excellent reliability. A 2019 update increased power from 155 to 181 horsepower, enhancing performance.
The manual soft top is easy to operate, and a retractable hardtop (RF) is available. Fuel efficiency remains impressive, making it a fun yet practical choice. For 2020, Apple CarPlay became available, and older models can be retrofitted.
This generation maintains strong reliability, ensuring an enjoyable ownership experience. The Miata is perfect for driving enthusiasts seeking a lightweight, engaging sports car.
Each used car pick offers a blend of reliability, value, and safety. With proper research and pre-purchase inspections, buyers can secure a dependable vehicle that meets their needs and budget. These selections represent some of the best used-car options available today.
Also Read: 10 Cars That Sound Better Than Any Aftermarket Exhaust on a Budget