Finding an affordable classic muscle car may seem impossible, especially with top-tier models like the Mustang Boss 429, Chevelle SS 454, and 426 Hemi Mopars commanding six-figure price tags.
However, budget-conscious buyers have options, such as taking on a project car, though restoration costs can quickly add up. Another approach is choosing lesser-known models like the Dodge Polara or Ford Fairlane, but these lack the prestige of more iconic muscle cars.
Opting for later models, such as a 1975 Plymouth Barracuda or Camaro, is another route, though post-1971 cars are often detuned and less powerful than their predecessors.
Fortunately, well-maintained, running classic muscle cars can still be found at reasonable prices. While they may lack top-tier engine options or matching numbers, they deliver the authentic muscle car experience without breaking the bank.
Using the base price of a 2025 Ford Mustang ($33,515) as a benchmark, buyers can find great deals on classic-era muscle cars that still turn heads.
This list, compiled using reputable sources like Bring a Trailer, Hagerty, and Classic.com, ranks vehicles by price from lowest to highest, making it easier for enthusiasts to find an affordable yet thrilling ride.
1. 1968 Plymouth Barracuda
The second-generation 1968 Plymouth Barracuda is an often-overlooked yet highly affordable muscle car, especially when compared to the more famous third-gen Hemi ‘Cuda.
Recently, a rust-free model with a 225ci slant-six and four-speed transmission sold on Bring a Trailer for just $10,750. While the interior needed some work, the sale included new seat covers, making it a solid deal. With its sleek design and classic appeal, the ’68 Barracuda offers muscle car enthusiasts an eye-catching ride at a budget-friendly price.
For those seeking more power, the second-gen Barracuda also comes with larger engine options that remain within an affordable range. A 318ci V-8 model is valued between $11,300 and $37,200 by Hagerty, while J.D. Power lists its high retail price at $25,700.
For those looking to push performance further, a 440-equipped Barracuda is pricier but still attainable, with well-maintained examples available for under $35,000. With a little effort, muscle car fans can find a great second-gen Barracuda that delivers both power and classic style without an exorbitant price tag.
2. 1968 Mercury Cougar
The 1968 Mercury Cougar, often overshadowed by its cousin, the Ford Mustang, is an underrated yet stylish muscle car that offers great value. It delivers the same classic appeal as a ’68 Mustang but at a more affordable price.
A completely restored 1968 Cougar with a 302ci V-8 recently sold on Bring a Trailer for just $17,500, making it an incredible deal.
Although the exterior and interior had been changed, the car appeared to have matching numbers, adding to its authenticity. With its unique design and muscle car heritage, the Cougar turns heads while being budget-friendly.
Despite some high-end sales, such as a rare GT-E 427 model selling for $165,000, most late-’60s Cougars remain relatively affordable. Hagerty values them between $11,200 and $28,800, while J.D. Power lists a high retail price of $58,800.
Generally, well-maintained V-8-powered Cougars can be found in the low to mid-$20,000 range, making them a smart choice for classic car enthusiasts. Their resemblance to the Mustang also adds to their appeal, often sparking curiosity and admiration wherever they go.
3. 1970 Plymouth Duster
The 1970 Plymouth Duster is one of the most affordable and attention-grabbing classic muscle cars. A fully restored drag-racing version with a rebuilt 440ci engine recently sold for just $18,750 on Bring a Trailer.
While not street-legal in its current form, it could be converted into an incredibly unique daily driver. With its racing pedigree and aggressive styling, the Duster proves that muscle car enthusiasts can still find thrilling, high-performance classics without breaking the bank.
For those who prefer a factory-spec model, the 1970 Duster remains one of the most budget-friendly Mopars available. J.D. Power lists the average retail price of a 340ci V-8 model at just $20,300, making it an incredible value.
While it may not have the same prestige as a Road Runner or Barracuda, it offers similar style and performance at a fraction of the cost. Even rare, high-end versions remain relatively affordable, solidifying the Plymouth Duster’s status as the ultimate budget-friendly muscle car.
4. 1971 Dodge Charger SE
The popularity of the Dukes of Hazzard and Fast & Furious franchises has driven second-gen Dodge Charger prices sky-high, making them unattainable for budget-conscious buyers. However, the third-generation Charger, particularly the 1971 model, remains a solid alternative.
While later years featured detuned engines and less desirable styling choices, the ’71 model retained much of the classic muscle car appeal. It offers a mix of aggressive design and strong performance without the hefty price tag associated with its more famous predecessor.
A pristine 1971 Dodge Charger SE with a matching-numbers 383ci Magnum V-8, producing 300 horsepower, sold for just $22,000 on Bring a Trailer. While that specific deal may be hard to replicate, well-maintained third-gen Chargers remain relatively affordable.
Expect to pay around $30,000 for a great-condition example, which is still a bargain compared to the price of a rusted, engineless second-gen project car. With its classic Mopar charm and reasonable cost, the ’71 Charger is one of the best ways to own a legendary muscle car without breaking the bank.
5. 1970 Pontiac Firebird Esprit
A 1970 Pontiac Firebird Esprit with a 400ci V-8 recently sold for just $26,500 on Bring a Trailer, making it a surprising addition to the list of affordable classic muscle cars. This particular model had been fully refurbished between 2018 and 2024, putting it in excellent condition.
While it featured a less desirable two-barrel carburetor and lacked a rear spoiler and sportier wheels, these are minor upgrades that can easily be addressed. Considering its condition and performance potential, this Firebird was an incredible deal for a second-generation classic.
Although finding a fully restored 1970 Firebird at this price is rare, project cars under $30,000 are still available for those willing to put in the work. Similar deals may surface again, proving that classic muscle cars can still be attainable with patience.
The 1971 Firebird becomes even more affordable with a 350ci V-8, as Hagerty values an excellent-condition model at $21,500, while a top-tier Concours-level example costs $32,600. This makes the early second-gen Firebird a compelling option for muscle car enthusiasts seeking a V-8 classic without an exorbitant price tag.
Also Read: 10 Best Plug-In Hybrid SUVs for Maximum Efficiency and Long-Distance Driving in 2025
6. 1971 Chevrolet Chevelle
The 1971 Chevrolet Chevelle is a surprising entry on a list of affordable classic muscle cars, but a recent sale on Bring a Trailer proves it’s possible. In January 2024, a beautifully restored ’71 Chevelle Sports Coupe sold for just $27,150.
However, this lower price comes with caveats—it’s not a matching-numbers car, nor is it a true SS model. Originally a six-cylinder, it was upgraded with a 350ci V-8 and given SS styling.
While this affects its investment value, to the average onlooker, it looks just as stunning as a genuine SS, making it a great option for someone who wants the Chevelle experience without the high cost.
Despite their abundance, Chevelles remain highly desirable, standing alongside the Charger as one of the most iconic muscle cars. Prices vary widely, with Hagerty listing a pristine 350ci model at $27,770, making it an attainable dream for many enthusiasts.
While most buyers covet the 454ci version, even those prices are not out of reach—J.D. Power estimates the average retail price at $50,100. For those willing to stretch their budget, a true high-performance Chevelle is still within reach, but for those on a tighter budget, well-restored tribute cars provide an excellent alternative.
7. 1971 Chevrolet Nova
The 1971 Chevrolet Nova, often seen as a second-tier muscle car like the Dodge Dart or Plymouth Duster, offers a great mix of affordability and performance. A fully restored ’71 Nova with a rebuilt 396ci V-8 recently sold for just $28,500, proving that powerful, classic muscle cars can still be found at reasonable prices.
Thanks to its compact size and potent engine, this Nova delivered both speed and style, making it an exceptional deal compared to higher-priced alternatives. Unlike many budget-friendly muscle cars that sacrifice performance, this Nova offered serious horsepower without breaking the bank.
Novas remains one of the best bargains in the classic muscle car market. J.D. Power lists the average retail price for a 1971 two-door coupe at just $13,900, though engine specifications are unclear.
Auction sites like Bring a Trailer and Classic.com have featured multiple V-8-powered Novas selling in the $20,000 range, reinforcing their status as an attainable muscle car option. For those willing to opt for a 307ci V-8 model, Hagerty values top-condition examples at only $26,100—an excellent price for a classic with both style and speed.
8. 1970 Dodge Coronet
A 1970 Dodge Coronet powered by a 440ci V-8 recently sold for just $29,000 on Bring a Trailer, making it an incredible deal for a classic Mopar. While it lacked matching numbers and had incorrect Super Bee graphics, these factors only matter from an investment perspective.
With 390 horsepower under the hood, this Coronet offers impressive performance and striking looks at a fraction of the cost of similar muscle cars. For buyers looking for an exciting driver rather than a collector’s piece, this deal is hard to beat.
Despite some Coronets reaching million-dollar valuations, more common models remain relatively affordable. Hagerty values a 318ci V-8 version between $8,600 for a fixer-upper and $29,600 for a top-condition example, making them one of the best Mopar bargains.
Fifth-generation Coronets were designed for the 440, so paying a little extra for one with the bigger engine is a worthwhile investment. J.D. Power estimates a 1970 Coronet R/T’s value between $13,200 and $49,800, though models equipped with a 426 Hemi command significantly higher prices, averaging around $94,000.
9. 1970 Ford Mustang Boss 302
For Mustang enthusiasts, the Boss 302 is an excellent alternative to the ultra-expensive Boss 429, offering both performance and affordability. A fully refurbished 1970 Ford Mustang Boss 302 recently sold for just $30,000 on Bring a Trailer, making it one of the best deals of the year.
This particular model was in immaculate condition, proving that with patience and research, great classic Mustangs can still be found at reasonable prices. With its aggressive styling and legendary performance, the Boss 302 remains a highly desirable muscle car without the sky-high price tag.
The 1970 Mustang was the last great model before Ford introduced the longer, less popular versions in 1971, making it a prime collector’s piece. Despite this, classic Mustangs can still be found at various price points.
Hagerty values 1971 Mustang 302 models between $7,500 and $25,000, while J.D. Power lists a 1971 two-door fastback with an average retail price of $39,800. While that figure likely applies to the 302 or 351 V-8 versions, it’s clear that classic Mustangs, even performance-oriented models, remain accessible for enthusiasts looking for a great deal.
10. 1971 Pontiac GTO
The 1971 Pontiac GTO remains an iconic muscle car, and while high-performance models like the 389 or 455 Judge are out of reach for budget buyers, great deals still exist. A pristine Lucerne Blue 1971 GTO with a 400ci V-8 and just 6,000 miles sold for $32,000 on Bring a Trailer in 2022.
This particular model was in excellent condition, with only a drivetrain rebuild, making it a rare find at that price. As one of the most significant muscle cars in history, the GTO continues to be a highly desirable classic without requiring a massive investment.
1971 marked the last strong year for the GTO before emissions regulations and detuning reduced its power, but affordable examples can still be found. Pricing varies, with Bring a Trailer sales reaching up to $140,000 and Hagerty valuing high-condition models at nearly $60,000.
However, as demonstrated by recent sales, it is possible to own a well-preserved second-gen GTO for less than the cost of a base model 2025 Ford Mustang. While the modern Mustang is a great performer, it lacks the vintage appeal, raw power, and head-turning presence of a classic American muscle car like the GTO.
Finding an affordable classic muscle car may require patience, research, and a willingness to compromise on originality or high-performance engine options. However, as this list demonstrates, there are still plenty of opportunities to own a piece of American automotive history without spending a fortune.
From underrated gems like the Mercury Cougar and Plymouth Duster to well-preserved icons like the Boss 302 Mustang and Pontiac GTO, these cars offer a thrilling driving experience and timeless styling at prices comparable to a brand-new base model Ford Mustang.
While prices for the most coveted muscle cars continue to climb, there are still great deals to be found on auction sites and classic car marketplaces. Whether you’re looking for a restoration project, a well-maintained driver, or a modified tribute car, there’s an option for every budget.
With careful shopping and an eye for value, muscle car enthusiasts can still find an exhilarating ride that delivers the power, nostalgia, and presence that make these machines so legendary.
Also Read: 10 Best Car Tuners That Unlock Extreme Performance and Customization