Most vehicles experience their highest rate of depreciation within the first five years on the road.
This means that if you’re in the market for a used car that offers substantial upfront savings and won’t continue to lose value at a rapid pace, opting for one around five years old is a smart move. This is especially true for hybrid vehicles.
When purchasing a used hybrid, choosing a model that is approximately five years old ensures that you’re still getting a relatively modern vehicle with plenty of life left.
These reliable hybrids offer excellent fuel savings, provide a comfortable and practical driving experience, and are built to last for years to come.
After thoroughly exploring the used car market, we’ve identified ten hybrid models that stand out for their value.
These vehicles not only provide exceptional reliability offering peace of mind when buying used but also come with a range of modern features, making it feel as if you’re driving a new car without the hefty price tag.
10. 2017 Ford Fusion
Average Used Price: $11,550 | Reliability Score: 84/100
Back in 2017, Ford aimed to appeal to a wide range of buyers with the Fusion, offering budget-friendly, upscale, sporty, and hybrid variants.
Although it faced strong competition in its segment, its affordability in the used market only enhances its overall value.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.0-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 188 HP
- Torque: 129 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 43 MPG
- Highway MPG: 41 MPG
- Combined MPG: 42 MPG
While it may not be the sportiest sedan of its era, the Fusion delivers a surprisingly enjoyable driving experience. However, the hybrid model isn’t particularly quick, taking around 9.1 seconds to accelerate from 0 to 60 mph.
Pros
- Wide range of customization options
- Upscale features available
- Stylish exterior design
Cons
- Lacks quick acceleration
- Base hybrid models have minimal standard features
- Ride quality can be a bit firm
9. 2017 Kia Niro
Average Used Price: $13,412 | Reliability Score: 83/100
The Kia Niro was designed from the ground up as a hybrid, which was relatively uncommon when it first hit the market.
With impressive fuel economy, generous interior space, and plenty of standard tech features, the 2017 model presents itself as a fantastic bargain.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 1.6-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: 6-Speed Auto-Shift Manual
- Horsepower: 139 HP
- Torque: 195 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 52 MPG
- Highway MPG: 49 MPG
- Combined MPG: 50 MPG
Performance-wise, the Niro prioritizes fuel efficiency over speed, but it keeps up well with its competitors and performs adequately at highway speeds. However, its transition between electric and gasoline power can feel slightly unrefined at times.
Pros
- More spacious interior than expected
- Highly affordable within its segment
- Outstanding fuel efficiency for a crossover
Cons
- Powertrain can be inconsistent
- Base models lack premium features
- Cargo space is somewhat limited
8. 2018 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid
Average Used Price: $16,002 | Reliability Score: 86/100
Despite being a budget-friendly mid-size sedan, the Hyundai Sonata offers remarkable value. Based on its appearance alone, you might assume it’s a much more expensive vehicle.
The 2018 model benefits from a mid-cycle refresh, introducing desirable features such as a seven-inch touchscreen, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.0-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic
- Horsepower: 193 HP
- Torque: 140 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 40 MPG
- Highway MPG: 46 MPG
- Combined MPG: 42 MPG
Rather than focusing on sportiness, the Sonata prioritizes a smooth and comfortable ride. The cabin is impressively quiet for a non-luxury sedan, making it an excellent choice for long drives.
However, if you’re looking for an engaging driving experience, this may not be the ideal option.
Pros
- Modern design and features for its age
- Generously equipped with standard technology
- Larger cargo space than many competitors
Cons
- Acceleration is on the slower side
- Lacks engaging driving dynamics
- Cabin features an abundance of hard plastics
7. 2017 Honda Accord Hybrid
Average Used Price: $17,270 | Reliability Score: 82/100
The Honda Accord has long been regarded as the go-to choice for an affordable mid-size sedan, consistently offering excellent value for money while outperforming many rivals.
The 2017 model follows this tradition, boasting a comfortable interior, advanced technology, and a dependable powertrain.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.0-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 212 HP
- Torque: 129 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 49 MPG
- Highway MPG: 47 MPG
- Combined MPG: 48 MPG
The Accord achieves an impressive balance between comfort and driving enjoyment. It accelerates faster than most competitors, reaching 0 to 60 mph in about 7.2 seconds.
While the ride is firm, it still absorbs road imperfections with ease. Though not a true sports sedan, the Accord can be quite enjoyable when pushed to its limits.
Pros
- Excellent ride quality and handling for its class
- Spacious and well-designed interior
- Comes well-equipped across all trim levels
Cons
- Infotainment system can be finicky
- Lacks ventilated seats in any trim
- Exterior styling blends in with everyday traffic
6. 2017 Toyota Prius
Average Used Price: $17,486 | Reliability Score: 85/100
If maximizing fuel economy is your top priority, the Toyota Prius has always been the ultimate choice. The 2016 model introduced a major redesign, which means the 2017 model still feels fairly modern for its age.
While it won’t provide any thrills behind the wheel, there’s no denying that it will help you save a significant amount of money on fuel.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 1.8-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 121 HP
- Torque: 105 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 58 MPG
- Highway MPG: 53 MPG
- Combined MPG: 56 MPG
The Prius is built with a strong emphasis on simplicity and cost-effectiveness. Its outstanding fuel efficiency and reputation for reliability are a testament to that philosophy.
However, driving enthusiasts will find it uninspiring behind the wheel. On the bright side, the 2016 redesign brought noticeable handling improvements, thanks to a more sophisticated rear suspension system.
Pros
- Best-in-class fuel efficiency
- Improved handling over previous generations
- Excellent cargo space
Cons
- Driving experience lacks excitement
- Unconventional dashboard layout may not appeal to everyone
- Acceleration is sluggish at best
5. 2019 Honda Insight
Average Used Price: $18,052 | Reliability Score: 77/100
The Honda Insight was originally introduced as the successor to the Honda Civic Hybrid at least, until Honda decided to bring back the Civic Hybrid once again.
The goal was to create a compact sedan that delivered excellent fuel efficiency while maintaining the practicality and appeal of a traditional car, a strategy that worked well in its favor.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 1.5-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 151 HP
- Torque: 99 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 55 MPG
- Highway MPG: 49 MPG
- Combined MPG: 52 MPG
For a compact hybrid, the Insight delivers surprisingly decent acceleration, reaching 0 to 60 mph in as little as 7.7 seconds.
At lower speeds, it can even drive for about a mile on electric power alone. Overall, the Insight stands out for its comfortable, quiet, and refined ride.
Pros
- Drives and feels like a conventional sedan
- Exceptional ride quality
- Quicker acceleration than most competitors
Cons
- Engine can sound rough under hard acceleration
- Infotainment system can be cumbersome to use
- Offers less cargo space than some rivals
4. 2016 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid
Average Used Price: $18,364 | Reliability Score: 86/100
The Toyota RAV4 stands as one of the most successful compact SUVs of all time. Toyota has built its reputation on simplicity and practicality, so introducing a hybrid version was a logical step. Despite its age, the 2016 model still has a lot to offer.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.4-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 194 HP
- Torque: 152 LB-FT
- Driveline: AWD
- City MPG: 34 MPG
- Highway MPG: 30 MPG
- Combined MPG: 32 MPG
The hybrid powertrain enhances the RAV4’s fuel efficiency while also adding a bit more power.
The driving experience is smooth and refined, with a seamless power delivery that makes city and highway driving effortless. Additional noise insulation in the cabin further improves overall comfort.
Pros
- Extremely practical and versatile
- Hybrid model is only slightly more expensive than the standard version
- Well-designed and user-friendly interior layout
Cons
- Steering lacks feedback and feels disconnected
- Brakes do not inspire confidence
- Exterior styling is somewhat bland
3. 2018 Toyota Camry Hybrid
Average Used Price: $20,390 | Reliability Score: 85/100
The Toyota Camry has long been associated with value, reliability, and comfort, and the 2018 model continues that legacy.
While older versions of the Camry were often criticized for being too plain, the 2018 model marked the beginning of a new generation, featuring a bold exterior design and improved driving dynamics.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.5-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 208 HP
- Torque: 163 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 51 MPG
- Highway MPG: 53 MPG
- Combined MPG: 52 MPG
Although it may not be as exciting to drive as some of its competitors, the hybrid Camry offers enough power to get you moving with ease.
Toyota’s refinements for the 2018 model year also result in significantly better handling compared to previous generations, while maintaining a smooth and composed ride.
Pros
- Spacious cabin with ample room for passengers
- Offers relatively modern technology features
- Exterior design is stylish and more appealing than before
Cons
- Lacks Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration
- Dashboard layout may not be to everyone’s taste
- Pricier than the similarly equipped Honda Accord Hybrid
2. 2018 Lexus ES 300h
Average Used Price: $23,878 | Reliability Score: 90/100
If you’re in the market for a reliable luxury sedan, few options on the used market surpass the Lexus ES.
While it may not be as aggressive or performance-focused as some other luxury vehicles in its class, it delivers exceptional comfort and refinement all at a highly competitive price.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.5-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 200 HP
- Torque: 156 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 40 MPG
- Highway MPG: 39 MPG
- Combined MPG: 40 MPG
For those who prioritize a smooth and comfortable driving experience over rapid acceleration or razor-sharp handling, the ES 300h is an excellent choice.
The ride quality is outstanding, and the cabin remains impressively quiet even at highway speeds.
Pros
- Elegant and stylish exterior design
- Exceptionally smooth ride
- Well-appointed and high-tech interior
Cons
- Lacks athletic driving dynamics
- Acceleration is on the slower side
- Some sought-after features are not included as standard
1. 2022 Ford Maverick Hybrid
Average Used Price: $26,124 | Reliability Score: 81/100
Although it lacks the refinements introduced in the facelifted 2025 model, the 2022 Ford Maverick remains one of the best compact pickups available.
Despite its small footprint, it offers outstanding practicality, featuring one of the most innovative truck bed designs and clever interior storage solutions.
Performance Specifications
- Engine: 2.5-Liter Hybrid Inline-Four
- Transmission: CVT
- Horsepower: 191 HP
- Torque: 155 LB-FT
- Driveline: FWD
- City MPG: 42 MPG
- Highway MPG: 33 MPG
- Combined MPG: 37 MPG
Although it isn’t as capable as its gas-powered counterpart, the hybrid Maverick still manages to tow up to 2,000 pounds and haul 1,500 pounds in its truck bed.
It offers sufficient power, reaching 60 mph in 7.7 seconds, and provides driving dynamics that feel more like a car than a traditional truck.
Pros
- Ingenious and functional truck bed layout
- Impressive payload capacity
- Highly practical and well-thought-out interior
Cons
- Ride quality is a bit firm
- Base trims come with minimal features
- Hyundai Santa Cruz offers superior towing capacity
