Buying a used car is a smart financial decision for many consumers, offering significant savings while still delivering reliable performance. However, the quality and value of used vehicles can vary greatly.
Recognizing this, Consumer Reports has compiled a list of the top 10 used cars currently on the market, based on criteria like reliability, fuel economy, safety features, and driving performance.
This guide covers a wide spectrum of options to suit different needs and budgets—from efficient hybrids to rugged pickups and sporty roadsters. Each recommendation helps ensure buyers make informed, confident decisions when shopping for a pre-owned vehicle.
1. Stylish and Affordable: 2016 Mazda6 (Under $10,000)
The 2016 Mazda6 shines in the under-$10,000 category, offering a perfect blend of style, performance, and efficiency. Its 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine provides both responsive acceleration and excellent fuel economy, averaging 32 mpg.
The driving dynamics are sharper than most midsize sedans, making it enjoyable for daily commuting. Inside, the cabin is upscale for the price, though rear-seat space is limited.
It includes available safety features such as forward collision warning and blind spot monitoring. Known for reliability, the Mazda6 is ideal for buyers looking for a budget-friendly, fun-to-drive vehicle that holds up well over time with minimal maintenance.
2. Reliable and Roomy: 2018 Toyota Corolla (Under $15,000)
The 2018 Toyota Corolla is a top choice under $15,000, offering exceptional reliability and comfort. With a spacious interior and a comfortable ride, it’s well-suited for both new and seasoned drivers.
Fuel economy stands at a solid 32 mpg overall, and the vehicle includes Toyota’s standard TSS-P safety suite with features like automatic emergency braking and lane departure warning.
Sportier trims like the SE and XSE add flair without compromising dependability. Thanks to Toyota’s reputation for longevity, many 2018 Corollas on the market today are still in great condition, often capable of surpassing 200,000 miles with regular upkeep.
3. Versatile and Practical: 2016 Honda CR-V (Best SUV Under $15,000)
For under $15,000, the 2016 Honda CR-V is a standout small SUV with a reputation for reliability and utility. Its 2.4-liter engine is paired with a CVT for smooth performance and returns a respectable 24 mpg overall. A mid-cycle refresh in 2015 brought improved crash safety and updated styling.
The interior is spacious, especially the cargo area, making it ideal for families or outdoor enthusiasts. Higher trims offer more advanced safety tech, although it’s mostly limited to the Touring version. If you’re seeking a well-rounded SUV with long-term durability, the CR-V is an excellent value in today’s market.
4. Fuel-Efficient Performer: 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid (Best Hybrid Under $20,000)
With a remarkable 52 mpg overall in its LE trim, the 2019 Toyota Camry Hybrid is an excellent pick under $20,000. It provides a refined driving experience, thanks to a smooth powertrain and well-insulated cabin. Standard features include forward collision warning and adaptive cruise control, enhancing both safety and convenience.
Later models in this generation also add Apple CarPlay support. The Camry Hybrid’s lithium-ion battery has proven to be exceptionally durable, and it rarely needs replacement within typical ownership periods. This model is perfect for drivers wanting a full-size sedan that blends efficiency, comfort, and long-term reliability.
5. Sporty and Smart: 2021 Kia Sportage (Best Small SUV Under $20,000)
The 2021 Kia Sportage earns its place as one of the best compact SUVs under $20,000. It combines stylish design, a smooth ride, and commendable handling for an enjoyable driving experience.
In 2020, Kia upgraded the infotainment system with a larger touchscreen and added key safety features like lane-keeping assist and automatic emergency braking.
While base trims deliver only average fuel economy, the overall value is high, especially with Kia’s excellent warranty coverage. If you’re looking for a newer SUV with modern features and solid performance, the Sportage is a smart and stylish option at a reasonable price.
Also Read: 10 Cars That Mechanics Recommend for Life-Long Reliability and 250,000+ Mile Potential
6. Efficient and Dependable: 2018 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid (Best Hybrid SUV Under $20,000)
For buyers focused on eco-friendliness and practicality, the 2018 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid is hard to beat. This SUV improves on its gas-only counterpart with better fuel efficiency—up to 8 mpg more—and smoother performance.
The hybrid powertrain doesn’t sacrifice interior comfort or cargo space, and its upgraded safety features and infotainment system make it a strong all-around vehicle.
Reliability and resale value are exceptional, and maintenance costs remain low, making it a top pick in the used hybrid SUV segment. It’s a great option for environmentally conscious drivers who still need room for passengers, groceries, or gear.
7. Sporty Yet Spacious: 2020 Mazda CX-9 (Best 3-Row SUV Under $20,000)
The 2020 Mazda CX-9 brings driving excitement to the family SUV segment, offering sharp handling and a turbocharged engine. Although it sacrifices some cargo space for agility, the cabin feels upscale and includes modern amenities like second-row captain’s chairs.
The 2020 update enhanced safety features, improving peace of mind for families. While it’s not the largest 3-row SUV, it excels in style, tech, and driving enjoyment.
Ideal for families who don’t want to compromise on the driving experience, the CX-9 is a compelling alternative to more utilitarian rivals, delivering luxury-like comfort without exceeding a $20,000 price tag.
8. Affordable Luxury: 2017 Lexus NX (Best Luxury SUV Under $20,000)
The 2017 Lexus NX is the top luxury SUV choice under $20,000, delivering a balance of comfort, performance, and refinement. Sharing a platform with the Toyota RAV4, the NX adds upscale materials, advanced technology, and a more powerful turbocharged engine.
Fuel economy is decent at 24 mpg, and hybrid versions perform even better at 29 mpg. Opting for the 2018 model includes more standard safety features.
The ride quality is smooth, and the cabin remains quiet even at highway speeds. With Lexus’ reputation for quality and reliability, the NX provides a luxury experience without the premium price tag.
9. Rugged and Reliable: 2015 Toyota Tacoma (Best Pickup Truck Under $20,000)
The 2015 Toyota Tacoma is a rugged pickup truck that excels in durability and off-road capability. It’s a top pick for those needing a reliable workhorse or adventure-ready vehicle. Although the driving position feels a bit dated, the Tacoma offers excellent performance in a variety of trims and configurations.
The TRD Off-Road version is especially capable and sought after. Thanks to Toyota’s engineering, these trucks often last well beyond 300,000 miles with routine maintenance. It also holds its resale value extremely well, making it a solid long-term investment for used truck buyers prioritizing longevity and capability.
10. Pure Driving Fun: 2019 Mazda MX-5 Miata (Best Sports Car Under $20,000)
The 2019 Mazda MX-5 Miata is a lightweight, fun-to-drive roadster that’s beloved by enthusiasts. In 2019, power was boosted to 181 horsepower, making it even more exciting on winding roads. Its rear-wheel-drive setup, manual transmission, and sharp steering deliver a true sports car experience, while fuel economy remains high.
The soft-top roof is easy to operate, and the simple interior keeps the focus on driving enjoyment. Miatas are also known for reliability and low ownership costs. If you want a joyful, engaging vehicle that’s affordable to own, the 2019 Miata is one of the best options available.
Choosing a used car doesn’t have to be stressful—especially with a clear, researched guide like this one. Consumer Reports’ list offers something for everyone: families, commuters, enthusiasts, and those on a budget.
These top 10 picks stand out for their reliability, performance, safety, and overall value, ensuring peace of mind for used car buyers. Whether it’s a fuel-efficient hybrid, a rugged pickup, or a luxurious SUV, these vehicles provide solid long-term satisfaction without the cost of a new model.
With proper maintenance, any of these vehicles can serve their next owners reliably for many years to come.
Also Read: 10 Best V6 Sports Cars That Don’t Sacrifice Reliability
