Pickup trucks may look rugged and reliable, but appearances can be deceiving. Some trucks suffer from severe reliability issues that cost owners thousands in repairs and downtime.
These models, plagued by engine trouble, faulty electronics, and transmission failures, are often frustrating to maintain and may even be contenders for lemon law claims.
Below are five trucks with worryingly low reliability scores according to J.D. Power—vehicles that consumers should avoid if they value peace of mind and dependable performance over flashy exteriors and big promises.
1. 2022 Chevrolet Colorado: Midsize Truck, Maximum Headaches
The 2022 Chevy Colorado offers a promising blend of compact size and decent towing ability, but its performance in the real world is underwhelming. It holds a shockingly low reliability score of 5 out of 100 from J.D. Power.
Owners frequently report transmission failures, electrical glitches, and poor body construction. Infotainment malfunctions and noisy rides further diminish its appeal.
Despite its efficient engine lineup, these persistent issues make long-term ownership costly and frustrating. With only one recall, problems are clearly systemic rather than fluke errors. It’s a truck that simply doesn’t live up to its design intentions.
2. 2019 Ford F-350: A Workhorse That Breaks Down Too Often
The 2019 Ford F-350 is a heavy-duty powerhouse with class-leading towing capabilities, but its dependability is shockingly poor. Scoring just 4 out of 100 in reliability, this truck struggles with issues across the board—from powertrain failures to electrical problems and faulty suspension.
Despite its workhorse image, constant repairs and 15 recalls make it a maintenance nightmare. Its costly upkeep and recurring failures lead many owners to regret their purchase. This model proves that raw capability means little if the truck can’t stay operational, earning it a spot on the list of pickups to avoid at all costs.
3. 2021 Ford F-150 Hybrid: Innovation Gone Awry
Ford’s first hybrid pickup, the 2021 F-150 Hybrid, aimed to revolutionize fuel efficiency in the segment. Unfortunately, it also introduced a slew of reliability problems. With a score of just 4 out of 100 from J.D. Power, this truck has frequent issues with its transmission, electrical system, and structural components.
Owners cite problems with power delivery and body integrity, while infotainment failures further frustrate daily use. Although maintenance costs are moderate, the high number of recalls—18 in total—speaks volumes. The truck’s cutting-edge tech may appeal to eco-conscious buyers, but it’s not worth the trade-off in reliability.
4. 2015 Dodge Ram 2500: Diesel Strength Overshadowed by Flaws
The 2015 Dodge Ram 2500 is well-known for its robust diesel engine, but it falters in overall reliability. Its J.D. Power score of 11 out of 100 places it among the least dependable trucks on the market. Major complaints include body integrity, transmission failure, and faulty turbochargers.
Many drivers also report malfunctioning power equipment and rapidly degrading structural components. Despite its impressive powertrain options, 15 recalls, and high maintenance costs makes it a risky purchase. The Ram 2500 is a textbook example of a truck that’s tough on paper but fragile in practice.
5. 2017 GMC Sierra 1500: Luxury Ride, Lemon Reality
The 2017 GMC Sierra 1500 was marketed as a more refined truck with a quiet, car-like ride. But under its upscale veneer lies a deeply flawed machine. With a dismal reliability score of 16, owners have reported repeated problems with its transmission and drivetrain, especially in colder conditions.
These problems often go unresolved despite visits to repair shops, due to their inconsistent nature. While comfortable inside, this model lacks mechanical dependability. Five recalls and long-term maintenance costs exceeding $9,000 confirm its reputation as a potential lemon. It’s best admired from afar, not owned.
Each of these five trucks serves as a cautionary tale. Despite impressive specs and appealing marketing, their poor reliability scores and costly issues make them potential lemon law candidates. Transmission failures, body defects, and unfixable bugs undermine what should be trustworthy work vehicles.
If you’re shopping for a truck that won’t drain your bank account in repairs—or your patience—these are models best left on the lot. Fortunately, not all trucks fall into this category. Some stand out as dependable options that deliver on their promises.
5 Trucks That Aren’t Lemon Lawsuits Waiting to Happen
While some trucks disappoint, others rise above the competition by delivering dependable performance year after year. These models earn high marks from J.D. Power and are backed by strong warranties and positive real-world owner experiences.
Whether used for hauling, off-roading, or daily driving, these trucks prove their worth with reliable engines, quality construction, and smart features. If you’re in the market for a pickup that won’t leave you stranded, the following five models offer peace of mind and solid long-term value.
1. 2025 Toyota Tundra: Comfort and Confidence Combined
The 2025 Toyota Tundra blends solid engineering with a plush interior and advanced tech. It offers three twin-turbo V6 powertrains and a standard 10-speed transmission. While its efficiency and towing capacity lag slightly behind rivals, its comfort and reliability shine.
Earning a J.D. Power reliability score of 82, the Tundra qualifies for a “Great” rating. Toyota backs it with comprehensive warranties, including extra coverage for hybrid components and the battery pack. For buyers looking for a smooth, tech-savvy ride with trustworthy performance, the Tundra is a top contender in the full-size pickup category.
2. 2025 Ford F-250 Super Duty: Built for Work, Built to Last
The 2025 Ford F-250 Super Duty doesn’t just deliver power—it delivers dependability. This heavy-duty pickup comes with four powerful V8 options, including two diesels. A J.D. Power score of 83 lands it squarely in the “Great” reliability tier. Diesel models enjoy extended powertrain coverage up to 100,000 miles.
Whether towing massive loads or handling tough terrain, the F-250’s design ensures it can endure long-term use. For drivers who demand a rugged truck that doesn’t quit, the Super Duty is one of the most dependable in its class.
3. 2025 GMC Sierra 1500: A Sophisticated and Strong Performer
The 2025 GMC Sierra 1500 offers a refined driving experience paired with robust capability. It’s available with a mix of engines—from efficient turbo-fours to V8s and a turbodiesel. Rear-wheel drive is standard, but four-wheel drive is widely available. With a J.D. Power reliability score of 83, it’s considered “Great” for long-term performance.
The Sierra also benefits from a well-appointed interior and user-friendly tech, making it ideal for daily driving as well as hard work. GMC’s strong warranty coverage and reliability rating make this truck a smart, well-rounded investment.
4. 2025 Toyota Tacoma: A Compact Truck with Consistent Quality
The 2025 Toyota Tacoma continues its legacy as a versatile and reliable compact truck. It features three turbocharged four-cylinder engines, including a hybrid, paired with either an automatic or manual transmission.
A reliability score of 79 gives it an “Average” mark, but its historical reputation and consistent performance make it a dependable choice. Toyota’s well-known build quality and generous warranty coverage contribute to its appeal. For drivers seeking a smaller truck that’s still tough and long-lasting, the Tacoma is hard to beat.
5. 2025 Ford F-150: America’s Favorite for a Reason
The 2025 Ford F-150 remains one of the best-selling trucks for good reason. With a wide array of powertrains and trim levels, it appeals to nearly every buyer. The twin-turbo V6 EcoBoost is a favorite for its balance of power and efficiency.
Though it earns a J.D. Power reliability score of 78—technically “Average”—its versatility and proven performance keep it at the top of buyer lists. It’s backed by solid warranties and decades of field-tested durability. For those who want a capable and configurable truck with reasonable reliability, the F-150 is still a standout.
While some trucks are notorious for mechanical failures, these five models stand as proof that reliability and performance can go hand-in-hand. From compact to heavy-duty, these pickups deliver strong J.D. Power ratings, comprehensive warranties, and real-world dependability.
Whether it’s the comfort of a Tundra or the power of an F-250, these trucks are smart choices for anyone who needs a vehicle they can trust. In a market full of flashy options, reliability is what truly sets a truck apart—and these models deliver where it matters most.
Also Read: 5 Cars That Keep Working in Texas Heat and 5 That Overheat Instantly
