Crossovers have become the go-to vehicles for drivers seeking versatility, comfort, and everyday practicality. But not all crossovers are built to last. While some models deliver rock-solid reliability, others are plagued by persistent mechanical and electronic issues.
In this guide, we break down five standout crossovers that are engineered for long-term dependability—vehicles you can trust mile after mile. We also shine a light on five that tend to leave owners frustrated with frequent trips to the repair shop.
Whether you prioritize peace of mind or want to avoid costly surprises, here’s what you need to know before buying your next crossover.
5 Crossovers That Go Forever
1. Lexus UX: Urban Efficiency and Reliability Champion
The Lexus UX is the most accessible model in Lexus’s lineup, but stands tall in quality and dependability. Its hybrid drivetrain ensures low fuel costs, while precise handling makes it ideal for city driving. The interior exceeds rivals like the Audi Q3 and BMW X1 in refinement.
With a stunning 99.8% reliability score, it’s the most reliable hybrid in What Car?’s study. The only consistent issue is the 12-volt battery, which can affect hybrid functions. Infotainment glitches persist, with random freezing noted in newer models. Despite these quirks, the UX remains a top-tier compact SUV in terms of reliability.
2. Buick Encore: Value-Driven and Comfort-Focused
The Buick Encore offers a practical alternative to luxury subcompacts by combining SUV-like design with long-term durability. Known for topping J.D. Power’s Initial Quality Study, it delivers high reliability and solid build quality.
The Encore GX variant adds upscale materials, excellent infotainment, and a quiet cabin, especially in the Avenir trim. However, it lacks the handling finesse of German rivals. Common complaints include weak throttle bodies and unexplained check engine lights.
Despite these issues, its competitive pricing, roomy interior, and focus on driving comfort make the Encore a strong contender in the subcompact crossover segment.
3. Honda HR-V: Clever Packaging and Stellar Dependability
The Honda HR-V excels in practical design and reliability. Honda’s Magic Seat system makes it uniquely versatile, allowing for upright storage of tall items. The HR-V received a perfect 5.0 reliability score from RepairPal, with low average maintenance costs of $301 annually.
Some drawbacks include thin paint prone to corrosion and occasional transmission issues like gear hesitation or grinding. The latest HR-V features a refreshed design with better insulation and ergonomic tweaks.
Now offered only as a hybrid (except in China), it meets stricter emissions standards. Though not visually striking, the HR-V remains a smart, reliable, and practical choice.
4. Mazda CX-5: Driving Joy Meets Lasting Quality
The Mazda CX-5 offers engaging handling that sets it apart in the compact SUV class. While not as agile as a sports car, it balances athleticism with comfort well. Consumer Reports ranks it second for compact SUV reliability, with a full 5-star predicted score.
The main issue involves faulty LED daytime running lights and turn signals, caused by gasket-related corrosion in the electrical connectors.
Still, the CX-5’s upscale interior, responsive steering, and quiet ride make it one of the most rewarding crossovers to drive. For those wanting both reliability and driving pleasure, the CX-5 hits a near-perfect sweet spot.
5. Toyota RAV4: Global Bestseller with Minimal Faults
The Toyota RAV4 continues to dominate global SUV sales with its well-rounded package of space, comfort, and trustworthiness. It offers excellent rear passenger room and intuitive infotainment. Reliability remains high, though issues have surfaced over time.
Common complaints involve vapor canister faults in the evaporative emissions system and inaccurate fuel gauge readings. These are relatively minor compared to the vehicle’s overall strengths.
Consistently at the top of owner satisfaction surveys, the RAV4 exemplifies what makes Toyota a benchmark for reliability. Whether for families or commuters, the RAV4 remains one of the most dependable and practical choices available today.
5 Crossovers That Constantly Need Repairs
1. Chevrolet Bolt EUV: Electric Value Undermined by Reliability
The Chevrolet Bolt EUV stands out for its affordability, peppy performance, and practical electric range of 247 miles, yet its reliability is a serious concern, earning just 1 out of 5 in predicted scores.
Owners have reported faulty electronics, water leaks, and electric motor issues. It features nimble handling, a spacious interior, and regenerative braking with one-pedal driving. Still, it lacks all-wheel drive, which limits its appeal in cold climates.
Priced competitively, even below $21,000 at some dealerships, it offers tremendous value—but its history of quality problems suggests it’s best suited for short-term leases rather than long-term ownership.
2. Jeep Compass: Off-Road Credibility with On-Road Compromises
The 2025 Jeep Compass earns a slightly better reliability score of 2 out of 5 but continues to suffer from outdated transmission parts and steering concerns. While uninspiring on pavement, it shines off-road thanks to its standard four-wheel drive and decent 200-horsepower turbocharged engine.
However, numb steering and a stiff ride hinder urban performance. It returns below-average fuel economy—24 mpg city, 32 highway—and the cabin quality varies significantly between trims.
Interior space is decent, though rear seating and cargo volume lag behind class leaders. Value pricing and current leasing deals improve its appeal, but it remains a mixed performer overall.
3. Dodge Durango: Muscle and Utility at a Cost
The Dodge Durango, especially in its Hellcat SRT form, offers wild 710-horsepower performance and 8,700-pound towing capability, but its predicted reliability score remains low at 2 out of 5.
While its appeal lies in brute strength and aggressive styling, the SUV shows its age in refinement and long-term durability. For 2025, Dodge introduces three special editions—Brass Monkey, Silver Bullet, and Hammerhead—but they’re mechanically identical and pricey, ranging up to $102,885.
Despite its performance credentials and continued demand, the Durango ranks #15 among three-row SUVs, far behind more balanced offerings like the Kia Telluride and Toyota Grand Highlander.
4. Buick Enclave: New Looks, Familiar Issues
The redesigned 2025 Buick Enclave sports a bolder exterior and a powerful 328-horsepower turbo-four engine, aiming to attract younger buyers. It also features a futuristic 30-inch curved display combining the gauge cluster and infotainment.
Yet, it still earns a 2 out of 5 reliability score due to ongoing powertrain and electrical system issues that have plagued previous models.
Competing against luxury-adjacent rivals like the Acura MDX and Hyundai Palisade, the Enclave struggles to fully stand out despite strong comfort and tech offerings. The Preferred trim presents the best value, balancing price, performance, and features, though reliability concerns remain hard to ignore.
5. Alfa Romeo Stelvio: Style and Speed, but Fragile Underpinnings
With a sleek design and sharp handling, the Alfa Romeo Stelvio tempts enthusiasts, but its predicted reliability score of 1 out of 5 is a major red flag. Electronics and complex onboard systems are common failure points.
While performance trims like the Quadrifoglio offer Ferrari-derived power, even base petrol and diesel models deliver strong acceleration and cornering. However, the ride can be harsh, cabin space is tight, and the diesel engine sounds coarse at low speeds.
Competing with the BMW X3 and Mercedes GLC, the Stelvio stands out visually but falls short in durability, making it a risky long-term choice.
When choosing a crossover, reliability should be as important as performance, style, or brand reputation. Models like the Lexus UX, Honda HR-V, Mazda CX-5, Buick Encore, and Encore GX prove that durability doesn’t mean sacrificing comfort or features—they truly “go forever.”
In contrast, crossovers like the Chevrolet Bolt EUV, Jeep Compass, Dodge Durango, Buick Enclave, and Alfa Romeo Stelvio consistently show red flags in long-term ownership.
These vehicles may offer exciting designs or unique strengths, but ongoing reliability issues make them costly risks. Ultimately, investing in a proven, dependable crossover ensures fewer repairs, less stress, and a better ownership experience.
Also Read: 5 Cars With Legendary Resale and 5 That Nobody Wants
