Tensions are escalating within New York City’s Adams administration over proposed legislation aimed at curbing e-bike-related fatalities and injuries. Mayor Eric Adams has publicly expressed support for a bill mandating registration and license plates for all electric bikes and scooters through the city’s Department of Transportation (DOT), akin to the process for cars at the state Department of Motor Vehicles.
This initiative was reiterated during a meeting with transit stakeholders in September. However, DOT Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez voiced opposition to the bill during a City Council hearing in December, citing concerns over potential enforcement bias against delivery workers, many of whom are immigrants struggling to make ends meet.
Clash Between Mayor and DOT Commissioner
Rodriguez’s objections have sparked significant friction, especially with City Councilman Robert Holden, who sponsored the bill. Holden rebuked claims that the legislation would disproportionately target delivery drivers, emphasizing that enforcing laws against traffic violations is not discriminatory. He expressed frustration that the mayor’s support for the bill has not resonated within the DOT. Holden criticized Rodriguez and Deputy Mayor of Operations Meera Joshi for allegedly sidelining Adams’ agenda and pushing their own anti-car policies, even demanding their resignation for failing to align with the administration’s priorities.
Despite internal dissent, Mayor Adams has reiterated his support for the legislation, emphasizing the dangers posed by reckless e-bike and e-scooter riders. In a recent podcast interview, he highlighted pedestrian safety concerns, particularly for seniors, citing examples of riders violating traffic laws, such as running red lights and riding on sidewalks. Adams has remained silent on Rodriguez’s public opposition to the bill but appears displeased with the commissioner’s divergence from his stance. Insiders report Adams is increasingly frustrated by Rodriguez’s actions, which some interpret as undermining the administration’s efforts to address e-bike safety comprehensively.
Also Read: City Council Proposes E-Bike Licensing Bill to Address Rising Accidents and Improve Public Safety
Rising E-Bike Crashes and Battery Fires
Statistics underscore the urgency of addressing e-bike-related risks. Over the past five years, 48 fatalities have occurred in NYC due to e-bike crashes, including 34 cyclists, 13 pedestrians, and one motorist. Additionally, there have been over 735 e-bike battery fires since 2019, resulting in 500 injuries and 30 deaths. Proponents of the legislation argue that mandatory licensing and registration could help identify responsible parties in such incidents, ensuring accountability and reducing the risk of future tragedies. However, concerns about enforcement fairness remain a key sticking point in the debate.
The Adams administration appears united in its goal to enhance e-bike safety but remains divided on how to achieve it. Mayoral spokesperson Liz Garcia emphasized that Adams, Rodriguez, and Joshi are aligned in their intent to address the issue collaboratively. The administration plans to work with the City Council on a comprehensive response, aiming to reduce accidents while considering the socioeconomic impact on vulnerable groups like delivery workers. As debates continue, the administration must balance public safety priorities with fairness and inclusivity in enforcement, ensuring the legislation achieves its intended goals without unintended harm.
Also Read: Williamsburg Bike Lane Sparks Safety Concerns and Petition for Removal Amid Child Incidents