When shopping for a car, many buyers assume that newer automatically means safer. But that’s not always true. Some older vehicles were engineered so solidly and loaded with time-tested safety features that they actually outperform newer models in real-world crash data and reliability.
In fact, some used cars are built like tanks, offering a sense of security that today’s tech-heavy, lightweight vehicles just can’t match. These cars may not have giant touchscreens or over-the-air updates, but they’ll keep you and your loved ones safer when it counts most—during a crash or mechanical failure.
At the same time, not all used cars are worth trusting with your life. Plenty of budget-friendly options on the market come with a dark history of safety recalls, poor crash test ratings, and long-standing mechanical issues that increase the risk every time you hit the road.
These are the cars that look like a deal until something goes very wrong at high speeds—or even during daily commutes.
5 Used Cars That Are Safer Than New Ones – 80 words
These vehicles are not just tough—they’re proven survivors. From high IIHS and NHTSA crash ratings to real-world owner experiences, these used cars have earned reputations as reliable fortresses on wheels.
They’re equipped with advanced safety features for their time and engineered with durable frames, crumple zones, and proven mechanical longevity.
When safety is your priority, these used models can easily outperform flashier, newer rides that rely too heavily on untested tech. They prove that sometimes, old-school durability beats modern gimmicks.
ALSO READ: 5 Performance Cars You Can Actually Daily Drive for 200k Miles and 5 That Fall Apart Fast
1. 2014 Volvo XC90
The 2014 Volvo XC90 is a benchmark in used vehicle safety. Built during Volvo’s peak safety-focused years, this SUV offers tank-like construction with top-tier crash test results.
It earned the IIHS Top Safety Pick and received five-star ratings from the NHTSA. Unlike many newer vehicles that rely on flashy infotainment systems and touchscreens, the XC90 focuses on occupant protection and proven mechanical reliability.
It comes with essential features like side curtain airbags for all three rows, Roll Stability Control, and Volvo’s WHIPS whiplash protection system—technology that’s been time-tested and highly rated.
The structural integrity of the XC90 is exceptional. Its strong roof, rigid body frame, and advanced crumple zones make it ideal for surviving both head-on and rollover accidents.
Owners and mechanics alike report that this SUV ages well. With proper maintenance, it easily crosses the 200,000-mile mark without major mechanical failures. Plus, because it’s a Volvo, replacement parts and repair expertise are widely available.
Many newer crossovers may feature more driver-assist features, but they often compromise on weight and structural safety. The 2014 XC90 is an old-school overachiever—built with durability in mind and engineered by a company that’s synonymous with vehicle safety.
For families or anyone prioritizing crash protection over screen size, this used SUV is still one of the best buys on the road.
2. 2012 Honda Accord
The 2012 Honda Accord is a near-perfect example of practical safety. Not only did it earn a five-star safety rating from the NHTSA and a Top Safety Pick from the IIHS, but it also boasts excellent long-term reliability and crash survivability. With its solid build quality and reinforced frame, the Accord delivers peace of mind for drivers on a budget.
This model comes with front, side, and curtain airbags as standard, along with stability and traction control—a combination that helps prevent and protect during accidents.
Honda also equipped the 2012 Accord with ACE (Advanced Compatibility Engineering) body structure, designed to redirect crash energy away from passengers. This structural technology is still considered one of the best in its class.
Moreover, this generation of the Accord was one of the last before Honda went fully digital inside. You get fewer distracting screens and more tactile, intuitive controls, helping drivers stay focused on the road.
Visibility is great, braking is responsive, and the steering is precise, which adds another layer of active safety.
Today, many owners still drive their 2012 Accords daily, crossing well over 250,000 miles with minimal issues.
That kind of longevity and crash-tested performance makes it a standout in the used market. For a midsize sedan that offers big-league safety without a luxury badge, the 2012 Accord delivers unmatched value.
3. 2011 Subaru Outback
The 2011 Subaru Outback has built its reputation not only as an adventurous crossover but also as a safe, dependable option for families and outdoor lovers alike.
Subaru’s legendary Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system comes standard, giving drivers superior traction in all weather conditions—a crucial factor in accident prevention.
It earned a Top Safety Pick from the IIHS and solid crash ratings across the board. The 2011 model includes electronic stability control, four-wheel ABS, front-seat side-impact airbags, and full-length curtain airbags.
More importantly, Subaru’s ring-shaped reinforcement frame absorbs and distributes impact energy efficiently, protecting passengers during collisions.
This generation of Outback also came before the touchscreen-heavy trend. Its simple, functional controls reduce distractions and offer excellent visibility, thanks to large windows and upright seating.
In terms of structure, it’s a sturdy, reliable workhorse. It drives more like a tall wagon than a top-heavy SUV, giving it superior balance and control, especially in emergency maneuvers.
Subaru engines from this era are known for longevity, particularly the non-turbocharged 2.5L H4. With routine maintenance, this Outback can run strong past 200,000 miles. It also has a lower center of gravity than most crossovers, contributing to a better safety profile.
If you’re looking for a used vehicle that thrives in snow and stands strong in a crash, the 2011 Outback is a tough contender to beat.
4. 2010 Mercedes-Benz E-Class
The 2010 Mercedes-Benz E-Class is proof that you don’t need to buy a new luxury car to get advanced safety.
Built like a fortress, this model is loaded with tech that was ahead of its time, including Pre-Safe systems that prepare the car when a collision is imminent, such as tightening seat belts and adjusting seat positions.
It earned a five-star Euro NCAP rating and performed well in U.S. crash testing. The E-Class includes nine airbags, active head restraints, adaptive brake lights, and Attention Assist, which detects drowsy driving.
The rigid chassis and advanced crumple zones absorb impacts like few other sedans in its category.
The cabin is designed for long-distance comfort and safety, with thick doors, solid soundproofing, and excellent visibility.
It was engineered during Mercedes’ peak years of overbuilt reliability, before cost-cutting began in later models. The E-Class from this generation still turns heads, but its greatest value lies in its safety-first build philosophy.
Best of all, depreciation works in your favor. You can now buy a 2010 E-Class for the price of a basic new economy car—without sacrificing safety, performance, or style.
It’s a rare find that blends safety, prestige, and long-term dependability.
If you’re in the market for a used luxury car that values your life more than its touchscreen size, the E-Class belongs on your shortlist.
5. 2013 Toyota Avalon
The 2013 Toyota Avalon is one of the most underrated used full-size sedans when it comes to safety and durability.
Built on Toyota’s rock-solid K platform, this generation Avalon scores a perfect five-star rating from the NHTSA and is equipped with numerous safety technologies that were ahead of their time.
Standard features include ten airbags, stability control, traction control, anti-lock brakes, and a robust crash-absorbing body structure.
The Avalon also boasts exceptional visibility, intuitive dashboard design, and strong brakes—all of which contribute to a safer driving experience.
Toyota’s reputation for bulletproof reliability shines through here.
The 3.5L V6 engine under the hood is known for its smooth power delivery and long lifespan, often surpassing 300,000 miles with regular maintenance.
Transmission issues are virtually unheard of, and the suspension is tuned for a balance of comfort and control.
Though newer models offer more tech gimmicks, the 2013 Avalon nails the fundamentals: solid construction, comfortable driving, and a safety system that works when it matters most.
It’s perfect for families, long-distance commuters, or anyone looking for a full-size sedan that doesn’t skimp on protection.
If you’re willing to look past flashy marketing and focus on real-world safety performance, the 2013 Toyota Avalon offers an incredible blend of security, comfort, and Toyota-grade reliability.
5 Used Cars That Are a Risk at Any Speed
These vehicles might be tempting for budget-conscious buyers, but their safety records tell a different story. With poor crash test scores, chronic reliability issues, and subpar build quality, these cars pose serious risks, especially at highway speeds.
While they may seem like bargains at first glance, the real cost could be far greater in the event of an accident. If you value your safety and peace of mind, these are the used cars you should think twice—or even three times—about before buying.
ALSO READ: 5 Compact Cars Built Like Tanks and 5 That Fall Apart on Potholes
1. 2007 Chevrolet Cobalt
The 2007 Chevrolet Cobalt gained notoriety for all the wrong reasons. Once hailed as a budget-friendly compact car, it quickly became the face of one of GM’s most infamous safety scandals.
Its defective ignition switch led to hundreds of crashes and multiple fatalities, ultimately sparking a massive recall that shook the industry.
Beyond the ignition issue, the Cobalt was never a safety superstar. It earned only mediocre ratings in IIHS crash tests and suffered from structural weaknesses in side-impact protection.
Standard safety features were minimal—no stability control, limited airbag coverage, and a lack of advanced restraint systems compared to competitors, even back then.
The interior materials feel cheap, and the build quality leaves a lot to be desired.
The steering is numb, the braking lacks confidence, and the chassis doesn’t inspire any sense of control. In a high-speed emergency maneuver or accident, the Cobalt offers minimal protection.
Even if recall repairs have been performed, the underlying design flaws and lackluster construction remain. Plenty of safer used options exist in the same price range, making it difficult to justify owning a Cobalt in 2025.
If your goal is to protect yourself and your passengers, skip the Cobalt. It’s a textbook example of why affordability should never come at the cost of safety, and how a car can be more dangerous than it looks.
2. 2005 Kia Spectra
At first glance, the 2005 Kia Spectra seems like a practical used car option—affordable, decent on gas, and compact enough for urban driving. But dig a little deeper, and its alarming safety track record becomes clear.
It received subpar crash test ratings from the IIHS, particularly in frontal offset and side impacts. The lack of structural rigidity in this model makes it a poor performer in real-world collisions.
Equipped with only the bare minimum in safety features for its time—dual front airbags, no stability control, and limited braking performance—the Spectra doesn’t inspire much confidence in emergencies.
Owners often report poor handling at high speeds, especially during sudden turns or braking situations, which further increases the risk of accidents.
While Kia has since made huge strides in safety and quality, their earlier models, like the 2005 Spectra, were built during a transitional phase marked by cost-cutting and minimal crash engineering. Many units now suffer from rust, aging suspensions, and outdated safety systems.
Even if the car has low mileage and a clean title, the underlying flaws in its crash structure and poor safety scores make it a questionable buy. There are far better used cars in the same price range with better protection and long-term value.
Simply put, the 2005 Spectra might save you money upfront, but it could cost you much more in the long run.
3. 2006 Chrysler PT Cruiser
Quirky design aside, the 2006 Chrysler PT Cruiser is more of a novelty than a dependable, safe ride. While it once enjoyed a cult following, its crash test scores and real-world safety data are troubling.
The NHTSA gave it average ratings, while the IIHS noted poor performance in side-impact and rear-impact crash scenarios.
The PT Cruiser lacks modern safety features, offering only the basics: front airbags and optional ABS.
Electronic stability control and side-curtain airbags were either missing or only available on higher trims, leaving base models significantly under-equipped.
Its retro styling sacrifices structural integrity—especially in the roof and rear—compromising safety in rollover or multi-car collisions.
Mechanically, the PT Cruiser is plagued with problems. Owners report frequent engine overheating, electrical gremlins, and transmission failures—all of which add to its unreliability on the road. These issues, coupled with poor visibility and clunky handling, make it feel unstable at high speeds.
To make matters worse, aging examples often suffer from body rust, worn-out suspension, and braking components that don’t perform well under stress. It’s a car that may look charming in a driveway but is anything but reassuring in an accident.
For a vehicle that prioritizes style over safety and substance, the PT Cruiser is a relic best left in the past. If peace of mind is important to you, steer clear—literally.
4. 2008 Dodge Caliber
The 2008 Dodge Caliber was Chrysler’s attempt to replace the long-running Neon, but it ended up being one of the more disappointing hatchbacks in its segment. Its uninspiring design is matched only by its below-average crash protection.
While it did receive some acceptable ratings in frontal crash tests, it performed poorly in side-impact evaluations by the IIHS—even with optional side airbags.
What makes the Caliber truly dangerous is its unpredictability. Steering is vague, braking is spongy, and body roll is excessive, especially at highway speeds.
Many owners have described the driving experience as unsettling—particularly when maneuvering in emergency situations.
On top of that, the Caliber is known for a laundry list of reliability issues. From failing CVTs (Continuously Variable Transmissions) to electrical faults and suspension problems, it’s a car that doesn’t age gracefully.
Combine that with low-quality interior materials and cheap construction, and you have a car that fails both in comfort and safety.
Though it might be available for a bargain price in the used car market, the Caliber is a gamble—one that’s not worth taking when your safety is on the line. Its lack of structural reinforcement and dated design puts it far behind its competitors in crash protection and drivability.
If you’re looking for a dependable, safe used car, this is one hatchback you should avoid.
5. 2009 Hyundai Accent
The 2009 Hyundai Accent might appeal to budget-minded drivers, but when it comes to safety, it’s hard to justify. Despite being a decent city car with good fuel economy, the Accent’s lackluster crash test scores and flimsy build quality make it a risk at any speed.
The IIHS gave the Accent “poor” ratings in side-impact tests, even with optional side airbags.
The car’s structure was deemed unstable during testing, meaning that the cabin could be easily compromised in a serious crash.
At the time, stability control wasn’t standard and was absent from most trims, significantly reducing its ability to avoid accidents in the first place.
Beyond the crash performance, the Accent suffers from sluggish acceleration, minimal weight, and weak braking—factors that make it less safe on highways or in emergency maneuvers.
Many owners also report suspension issues, underwhelming headlights, and reliability problems as the vehicle ages.
It’s a classic example of a car designed for affordability first, safety second. In today’s market, better-equipped used cars like the Honda Fit or Toyota Yaris from the same era offer far superior safety and reliability without breaking the bank.
If you’re tempted by the Accent’s low price tag, consider the bigger picture. You might save money upfront, but you’ll be compromising on one of the most important aspects of car ownership: your safety.
In a world obsessed with the newest tech, it’s easy to assume newer means safer. But as we’ve seen, that’s not always the case. Several used cars—like the Volvo XC90, Honda Accord, and Toyota Avalon—combine real-world crash data, dependable engineering, and long-lasting performance to prove that age doesn’t always equal risk.
These vehicles were built with solid materials, equipped with tested safety systems, and refined through years of production—qualities many brand-new budget models still lack.
On the flip side, cars like the Chevy Cobalt and Kia Spectra show that some vehicles are fundamentally flawed. Whether due to design oversights, lack of safety features, or poor crash test results, these cars are ticking time bombs on the road. While they may be tempting for first-time buyers or those looking to save a few bucks, they could cost far more in the event of an accident, or even worse, in lives.
The bottom line? Do your homework. Used doesn’t have to mean unsafe, but not all used cars are created equal. Choose models with proven safety records, solid build quality, and dependable reputations. Because when it comes to driving, nothing matters more than making it home safe.
