Buying a car is only the beginning of its financial commitment. Insurance premiums, routine servicing, and unexpected repairs can make a significant difference to long-term ownership costs.
Some performance cars illustrate this cost imbalance particularly well, with annual insurance premiums sometimes exceeding typical maintenance and repair expenses. Insurify data identifies models with especially high insurance costs, while RepairPal provides estimates of their yearly repair expenses.
Consumer Reports adds useful context through its research on vehicle ownership costs. The figures are averages, not guaranteed bills, but they reveal some surprising differences between these expenses.
1. BMW M4
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,832
RepairPal estimated annual maintenance and repair cost: $2,781
The BMW M4 combines everyday usability with the performance of a serious sports coupe, but it is an expensive insurance policy. Insurify’s vehicle data places its average annual full-coverage premium at $3,832, making it the most expensive BMW model in the company’s listed comparison.
That figure is notably higher than RepairPal’s estimated average annual maintenance and repair cost of $2,781. The difference is approximately $1,051 per year, before accounting for fuel, tires, registration, depreciation, or loan payments.
There are understandable reasons why insurers may charge more for this car. The M4 is a high-performance vehicle, and its powerful engine, expensive components, and premium construction can increase the potential cost of an insurance claim.
The M4’s purchase price is another important factor, as repairing or replacing damaged components can be considerably more expensive than doing the same work on a typical family sedan. Insurers consider these potential costs alongside other factors, including the driver’s age, location, claims history, and chosen coverage.

RepairPal’s $2,781 estimate should not be mistaken for a fixed annual service bill. It represents an average, and actual expenses depend on the car’s age, mileage, condition, and where the work is performed. A major component failure or a set of performance tires can push an owner’s spending much higher in a particular year.
Nevertheless, the comparison highlights an important aspect of ownership. Even when maintenance costs are relatively predictable, insurance can remain a more significant recurring expense. Anyone considering a new or used M4 should get insurance quotes before making a purchase, rather than assuming the vehicle’s price reflects its full cost of ownership.
2. Nissan GT-R
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,815
RepairPal estimated annual maintenance and repair cost: $920
The Nissan GT-R has earned its reputation through formidable acceleration, advanced all-wheel-drive engineering, and a twin-turbocharged V6. Yet its performance credentials come with an insurance bill that can be surprisingly high.
Insurify lists an average annual full-coverage premium of $3,815 for the GT-R. RepairPal, by comparison, estimates its average annual maintenance and repair expense at $920. That creates a gap of approximately $2,895, meaning the estimated insurance premium is more than four times the repair-cost figure.
This difference does not mean the GT-R is inexpensive to own or that every example will cost just $920 a year to maintain. RepairPal’s figure is an average across the vehicles represented in its data, and an individual GT-R can require much more expensive work.
Its specialized drivetrain, turbocharged engine, braking hardware, and performance-focused components demand appropriate servicing. Previous track use, modifications, neglected maintenance, and high mileage can also change the financial picture considerably.
Insurance companies have a different calculation to make. They consider the cost of replacing the vehicle, the price of repairing collision damage, the likelihood and severity of claims, and the driver’s personal risk profile.

A high-performance sports car can therefore attract a substantial premium even when its estimated routine repair spending appears comparatively modest.
The GT-R clearly highlights the difference between the two costs. Maintenance estimates cover expected workshop expenses, while insurance provides protection against a much broader range of financial risks. Buyers should consider both expenses before investing in this Japanese performance icon.
3. Toyota GR 86
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,757
RepairPal annual maintenance estimate: Not available
The Toyota GR 86 is an interesting entry because it challenges the assumption that an expensive insurance policy always belongs to an expensive luxury car.
This lightweight sports coupe has a much lower starting price than many high-performance European models, yet Insurify reports an average annual full-coverage insurance premium of $3,757. That puts it third on the company’s list of the most expensive cars to insure.
The GR 86 delivers an engaging driving experience through a straightforward performance setup. It features a naturally aspirated 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine, rear-wheel drive, and a choice of six-speed manual or automatic transmission. Rather than focusing on high horsepower, the car prioritizes responsive handling and driver engagement.
However, insurers do not judge a vehicle only by its purchase price. Accident frequency, repair costs, vehicle performance, claims history, and the characteristics of drivers who own similar models can all influence premiums.
There is an important limitation when comparing its insurance with maintenance. RepairPal currently says it does not have enough information to provide an accurate annual maintenance figure for the GR 86.
Toyota’s maintenance coverage should also be considered separately. New GR 86 models come with ToyotaCare, which covers factory-scheduled maintenance for two years or 25,000 miles, whichever comes first. However, this is a limited benefit for new vehicles and should not be mistaken for a long-term estimate of annual maintenance and repair costs.

Consequently, the $3,757 insurance figure is verifiable, but claiming that it exceeds the GR 86’s average annual maintenance expense would go beyond the available evidence. Buyers should still request insurance quotes before purchasing.
A relatively affordable sports car can carry a premium that surprises drivers, particularly younger owners or those living in areas with higher insurance rates.
4. Maserati Ghibli
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,741
RepairPal annual maintenance estimate: Not available
The Maserati Ghibli brings Italian styling and luxury-sedan performance into a category where ownership costs can be considerably higher than the purchase price initially suggests.
Insurify places it fourth among its most expensive cars to insure, with an average annual full-coverage premium of $3,741. That is a substantial recurring expense, even before the owner accounts for fuel, tires, scheduled servicing, or unexpected mechanical work.
The Ghibli was sold in the United States with different powertrains over its production run, including twin-turbocharged V6 versions and the high-performance V8-powered Trofeo.
These variations matter because insurance costs and maintenance requirements can differ by model year, engine, trim, and vehicle value. A Trofeo, for example, should not automatically be treated as financially equivalent to an earlier V6 model.
RepairPal does not list a verified annual maintenance and repair cost for the Ghibli in the data available for this comparison. This gap is important because using figures from another Maserati model or a generic luxury-car estimate could result in an inaccurate and misleading comparison.
Open Labor Project provides a separate estimate for maintenance labor on a 2025 Ghibli, but that is based on a particular engine and assumed labor rate, so it is not interchangeable with a complete national annual ownership average.

What can be established is that the Ghibli attracts a high insurance premium in Insurify’s dataset. Its luxury positioning, powerful engine options, and potentially expensive replacement parts help explain why insurers may price coverage above that of an ordinary midsize sedan.
However, the available sources do not establish that $3,741 is higher than the Ghibli’s typical annual maintenance bill. Owners should compare quotes for their exact model year and trim before buying.
5. Tesla Model 3
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,602
Manufacturer’s estimated annual maintenance: $257 to $499
The Tesla Model 3 makes a strong case for why insurance and maintenance need to be considered separately when choosing an electric vehicle. Insurify reports an average annual full-coverage insurance cost of $3,602, placing the sedan fifth on its list of the most expensive models to insure.
Tesla, meanwhile, estimates annual maintenance spending for the Model 3 at between $257 and $499. On those figures, insurance is substantially more expensive than the manufacturer’s maintenance estimate.
The difference is partly explained by what each expense covers. Electric vehicles do not need conventional engine oil changes, spark-plug replacements, or exhaust-system servicing.
The Model 3 still requires attention to tires, brakes, cabin air filters, brake fluid, and other components, but its routine maintenance schedule differs from that of a gasoline-powered sedan.
Insurance is a much broader financial calculation. A policy can cover collision damage, theft, liability, and other covered events.
The cost of repairing a damaged electric vehicle can also be influenced by its battery system, body structure, sensors, cameras, and other technology. Insurers assess potential claim severity as well as the likelihood of a claim, so lower routine maintenance does not automatically produce cheaper coverage.
Tesla’s maintenance estimate should not be confused with a guarantee that every owner will spend less than $499 each year. Tire replacement, collision repairs, out-of-warranty faults, and other unexpected expenses can increase the bill.

The estimate also comes from the manufacturer, whereas the insurance figure is an average derived from Insurify’s insurance data. They are useful reference points, but they are not a controlled comparison of the same owners and vehicles.
Even with that qualification, the Model 3 is one of the clearest examples in this list of insurance potentially costing several times more than routine maintenance.
6. Mercedes-Benz GLE Coupe
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,583
RepairPal model-specific annual estimate: Not available
The Mercedes-Benz GLE Coupe combines the elevated driving position of an SUV with a sloping roofline and styling intended to give it a more sporting character. That combination comes with a premium insurance cost. Insurify lists its average annual full-coverage premium at $3,583, making it the sixth most expensive model to insure in the company’s comparison.
Unlike a conventional family crossover, the GLE Coupe is positioned in the luxury market. Depending on the model year and trim, buyers may find turbocharged six-cylinder engines, high-output AMG versions, advanced driver-assistance equipment, and sophisticated suspension systems.
These features can make the vehicle more expensive to repair after an accident. Large body panels, specialist lighting, sensors, and electronic systems can also add to the cost of restoring it to its original condition.
There is a distinction between the GLE Coupe’s insurance figure and the available maintenance data. RepairPal provides an average annual maintenance and repair cost of $908 for the Mercedes-Benz brand, but this is a manufacturer-wide figure.
It is not a verified GLE Coupe estimate and should not be presented as one. A particular AMG version, for example, may have different service and repair expenses from a standard model.

The $3,583 insurance estimate is therefore useful for understanding the model’s position in Insurify’s data, but the available evidence does not establish the exact gap between insurance and maintenance for this specific SUV.
Prospective owners should obtain quotes using the exact year, trim, ZIP code, and driver details. That step is especially important when comparing a standard GLE Coupe with a more powerful AMG variant, because their insurance costs may differ considerably.
7. Tesla Model X
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,510
RepairPal model-specific annual estimate: Not available
The Tesla Model X is a premium electric SUV with distinctive features, including its available third-row seating and rear falcon-wing doors. Its technology-rich design makes it different from a conventional gasoline-powered SUV, but that sophistication can also make insurance more expensive.
Insurify reports an average annual full-coverage premium of $3,510, placing the Model X seventh among the most expensive vehicles to insure in its current comparison.
One factor worth considering is the vehicle’s construction. The Model X uses a large battery pack and a complex electric drivetrain, alongside cameras, sensors, electronic controls, and specialized body components.
Damage to these systems can require specialist diagnosis and repair. The falcon-wing doors also have a more complicated mechanism than conventional rear doors, which can make certain repairs more involved. These features do not mean every accident results in a costly repair, but they help explain why insurers may account for higher potential claim expenses.
RepairPal does not currently have enough data to publish an accurate annual maintenance figure specifically for the Model X. It does report an average annual maintenance and repair cost of $832 across Tesla vehicles as a brand, but that number includes different models and should not be treated as the Model X’s individual cost.
Routine electric-vehicle maintenance can be less extensive than servicing a traditional gasoline SUV. There is no conventional engine oil to replace, for example, although tires, brakes, filters, suspension components, and other systems still need attention.

Unexpected repairs and collision damage are separate expenses that can change the ownership budget significantly.
The Model X clearly has a high insurance estimate, but the available sources do not provide a fair model-to-model annual maintenance comparison. Buyers should check insurance costs before committing to this expensive electric SUV rather than assuming that fewer routine service requirements will make it inexpensive to own.
8. Tesla Model Y
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,457
Manufacturer’s estimated annual maintenance: $316 to $643
The Tesla Model Y is a more practical electric SUV than the Model X, but its insurance costs remain high. Insurify lists its average annual full-coverage premium at $3,457, making it the eighth model in the company’s most-expensive-to-insure ranking.
Tesla estimates annual maintenance costs between $316 and $643, which is considerably lower than the insurance figure.
The Model Y’s appeal is built around electric performance, interior space, and everyday usability. Its electric powertrain eliminates several routine service requirements associated with gasoline vehicles, including engine oil and filter changes, spark-plug replacements, and exhaust-system maintenance.
That can make scheduled maintenance relatively straightforward, although owners still need to monitor tire wear, brake condition, cabin filters, and other components.
Insurance is calculated differently. The insurer must consider the potential cost of repairing or replacing the vehicle after a collision, along with theft risk, claim frequency, and the driver’s personal circumstances.
Electric vehicles can involve expensive components and specialized repair procedures. Even a relatively minor accident may require attention to sensors, cameras, body panels, or other systems that are integrated into the vehicle.
Tesla’s maintenance range is a manufacturer estimate, not a promise that every owner will spend within those limits. It does not mean collision repairs, tire replacement after heavy use, or unexpected failures will be covered by that amount. Likewise, Insurify’s premium is an average, not a quote that every Model Y driver will receive.

Still, the two published figures make the Model Y a useful example of how insurance can outweigh routine maintenance by a wide margin.
Anyone considering one should compare insurance offers from several companies and check the coverage limits carefully. A lower premium is not necessarily a better deal if it comes with substantially less protection.
9. Toyota Supra
Average annual full-coverage insurance: $3,427
RepairPal estimated annual maintenance and repair cost: $561
The Toyota Supra closes Insurify’s published list of the nine most expensive models to insure. Its average annual full-coverage premium is $3,427, a figure that may surprise buyers who associate Toyota with affordable ownership.
The Supra is not an ordinary commuter car, however. It is a rear-wheel-drive sports car developed around performance, with a turbocharged engine and a chassis designed for responsive handling.
RepairPal estimates the Supra’s average annual maintenance and repair cost at $561. Comparing that with the insurance estimate produces a difference of $2,866 per year.
These are averages from separate datasets, so the gap should be treated as an illustration rather than a guaranteed saving or bill for an individual owner. RepairPal’s estimate can vary with age, mileage, location, and repair facility.
The Supra’s performance character helps explain why its insurance costs are higher than those of many everyday Toyota models. Insurers assess the vehicle’s power, value, potential repair expenses, and claims patterns.
A sports car may also be more expensive to repair after collision damage because of its specialized components and bodywork. The driver’s age, location, driving history, and coverage choices remain important factors, too.

Maintenance is not necessarily cheap every year simply because RepairPal’s average is relatively modest. Tires, brakes, fluids, and scheduled services still require attention, particularly when the car is driven enthusiastically. A major mechanical repair can also exceed the annual average by a considerable amount.
Nevertheless, the published figures show a clear difference between estimated insurance and typical repair spending. For buyers attracted to the Supra’s performance, obtaining an insurance quote before purchasing is a sensible way to avoid an unexpected ownership expense.
